Jeffbert
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2011
- Messages
- 1,916
I too, watched this film, and began wondering just what elements must be present for a film to be 'NOIR'?The Captive City (1952), dir. Robert Wise; starring John Forsythe, Joan Camden
Part of the Noir Alley presentations from Turner Cable Movies, introduced by Eddie Muller. Muller explained this isn't really film noir -- there are some trappings of noir, though I'd agree -- but it is the first movie in the 1950s shifting the focus of crime movies away from the personal and more toward the social. This comes in the wake of the United States Senate Special Committee to Investigate Crime in Interstate Commerce led by Senator Estus Kefauver, who liked the movie enough to provide a filmed statement that runs after the movie.
When a private detective is murdered, an integrous small city newspaper editor becoming aware of the effects of a local bookmaking operation taken over by organized crime. Slowly he pieces together the corruption under the city's administration and business leaders he'd been unaware of during his five years as a resident and has to decide what to do about it.
Forsythe's first starring role, this is a nicely done, fairly straight-forward crime movie, based (loosely, I imagine) on Newsweek articles by one of the screenwriters. Early use location shooting rather than studio back lots for crime movies. Not great, but as watchable as every other movie I've seen from Wise.
Randy M.
True, there are obvious things lacking, such as a femme fatale, a mastermind plotting a heist, etc. But the little guy, a editorial writer/1/2 owner of the local newspaper, trying to find out the whys and wherefores of the town's corruption. His being opposed by just about everyone whom he trusts, etc. Is this not noir?
Anyway, one thing I noted Muller not commenting about, is the police corruption, and that such a topic would be rather unpopular. Who wants to even imagine your local cop is on the take? But on this, Muller is silent.
Damn, I hate February! No Noir Alley! August, too! Just one more NOIR ALLEY this month, and then nothing until March. & this is leap year!