units of measurement

AllanR

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2021
Messages
138
Location
Canada
instead of necroing an old thread...

If if read a futuristic sci-fi and the author uses imperial
--if the story was wrote in the 90s or later, I assume the author doesn't know much science. Probably an unfair assumption, yet one that happens nonetheless. It is a stumbling block and if I were to hit another one or two blocks right off, I would discard the book.
Basically if the story involves off Earth by human tech it should be metric imo. Science uses metric, NASA uses metric, imperial causes rockets to get lost. It requires me to suspend my disbelief when I encounter imperial here. (of course some authors produce their own units with great success)

If it was steam punk in the USA I would expect imperial.
 
Last edited:

Foxbat

None The Wiser
Supporter
Joined
Jul 24, 2003
Messages
8,889
Location
Scotland
If we take measurements in radiation as an example. I choose this as an example because it throws up an anomaly. The becquerel is the international unit (SI) used in Europe and this is based on a disintegration per second within a nucleus. In the USA, the older unit called a Curie is still used. This is based on 37 billion disintegrations per second derived from the decay of one gramme of Radium. This means that instead of using Sieverts and Grays for measuring diposes (as per the SI system), Nasa still uses Rads and Rems despite going metric for other measurements.
 

AllanR

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2021
Messages
138
Location
Canada
I was a teen when my country switched. So many people use a weird mix of both in everyday life. Feet for people's height, C for temp, km for short distances or long, intermediate however are measured by driving time. cm for rain, inches in construction, litres for fuel or drinks....
At the time of switch the math texts replaced feet for metres and question like 'A six meter tall man...."

Sorry btw for the tone of the first post, I mustn't have had my coffee yet :/

Nasa still uses Rads and Rems despite going metric for other measurements.
I had no idea Nasa uses rads and rems instead of sieverts and grays
 

CupofJoe

Some medals you wear on your heart not your sleeve
Joined
Mar 29, 2019
Messages
769
When I'm prepping for a story... If it is fantasy I will default to some version of imperial, but it is contemporary or sci-fi it will be metric.
Oddly 0c feels colder than 32f but 86f feels warmer than 30c.
 

Foxbat

None The Wiser
Supporter
Joined
Jul 24, 2003
Messages
8,889
Location
Scotland
Coffee is always a good starter.

I was once ridiculed as an apprentice when I did a measurement that was something like one metre, five inches:D
 

The Ace

Scottish Roman.
Joined
Jun 6, 2006
Messages
4,980
Location
Aye. Have a dream !
SI Units are a strictly modern phenomenon in the English-speaking world, and any media from here created up until the 1960s would use Imperial measurements (one of the attractions of, "Star Trek," was the use of metres and kilometres, which struck me as very advanced at the time).

I was in primary school when it was decided that the UK would convert to metric in the future, and the new generation should learn the new system, just as we were getting our heads around inches/feet or ounces/pounds/stones, with the result that I can visualise 6 inches or 20 feet, but haven't a clue what a meter is. (We changed to decimal coinage at the same time, which made things even more fun)

Just about every school ruler and measuring-tape in the UK is calibrated in both imperial and metric even now, and please don't mention Arshins to me.
 

Fiberglass Cyborg

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
101
SI Units are a strictly modern phenomenon in the English-speaking world, and any media from here created up until the 1960s would use Imperial measurements (one of the attractions of, "Star Trek," was the use of metres and kilometres, which struck me as very advanced at the time).

I was in primary school when it was decided that the UK would convert to metric in the future, and the new generation should learn the new system, just as we were getting our heads around inches/feet or ounces/pounds/stones, with the result that I can visualise 6 inches or 20 feet, but haven't a clue what a meter is. (We changed to decimal coinage at the same time, which made things even more fun)

Just about every school ruler and measuring-tape in the UK is calibrated in both imperial and metric even now, and please don't mention Arshins to me.

By my generation we'd arrived at a wierd hybrid of measuring conventions. Roughly as follows:

Lengths and distances: people and roads in imperial; everything else in metric
Weight: people mainly in imperial; food mainly in metric; Heavy goods ?!?!?!?!?
Volume: milk and beer in imperial; everything else in metric.

This makes it pretty hard to make connections across categories and scales....
 

Astro Pen

Write now.
Supporter
Joined
Jan 24, 2020
Messages
926
Location
Wales UK
Miles per Gallon
Miles per Hour
Pint of beer
Six foot man
12 stone
26 inch TV
14 pounds per square inch
Deep six
32 inside leg
size 10 clod hoppers.
Cruising at an altitude of 20 thousand feet.

Certainly to a Briton of my advanced age none of these standards sound remotely fluid in writing when converted to to their metric equivalents. In fact they really jar on the nerves. The external mental juggling of interpreting them pulls one out of the story.
(And metric tonne up boys don't impress me either ;))

I will however concede that decimal currency was an absolute boon after schoolboy battles with compound interest in Pounds Shillings and Pence.
 

tinkerdan

∞<Q-Satis
Joined
Dec 10, 2012
Messages
5,103
Location
x² + y² = r²:when x~∞
I tend to have an odd combination since in my work I end up using both because US manufacturers of components still use inches and mils.
With that in mind I tend to write with an odd mix and then sort it out before I send to anyone. For the SF I tend to try to stick to metric.

Here in the US we still have challenged people in our military industry. At work, I remember an irate phone call from a member of a 'to remain unnamed organization' that they thought I should have sent a mounting diagram with "American Measurements". I said, "I'm sorry, but it was manufacture using those metric measurements." And since his concern was the screw for a mounting hole I had to remind him that--for best fit--he should use the type of screw suggested.
 

Fiberglass Cyborg

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
101
At work, I remember an irate phone call from a member of a 'to remain unnamed organization' that they thought I should have sent a mounting diagram with "American Measurements". I said, "I'm sorry, but it was manufacture using those metric measurements." And since his concern was the screw for a mounting hole I had to remind him that--for best fit--he should use the type of screw suggested.

Headline: 'Bomber Breaks Up In Fight Due To 1/8" Screws in 4mm Holes.'
 

psikeyhackr

Physics is Phutile, Fiziks is Fundamental
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,429
instead of necroing an old thread...

If if read a futuristic sci-fi and the author uses imperial
--if the story was wrote in the 90s or later, I assume the author doesn't know much science. Probably an unfair assumption, yet one that happens nonetheless. It is a stumbling block and if I were to hit another one or two blocks right off, I would discard the book.
I think your point is valid but I still don't think in metric. Unless some measurement in a story obviously makes no sense I probably ignore it.

In his book Destroyer, Chris Fox said the galaxy rotated in 26,000 years. That really pissed me off. I guit reading it. It is actually about 200,000,000 years. I don't know what the error margin is. I have also seen 220 million. 26,000 would require stars at the outer edge to travel faster than light.
 

Similar threads


Top