Dave Vicks
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2020
- Messages
- 1,718
THE STRANGER BESIDE ME.1980.
Ann Rule.
True Crime .
Ann Rule.
True Crime .
A flatmate of mine at university in the late 1980s was very keen on these books. I think I read the first couple of stories at her insistence and was not enthused, probably due to the lack of spaceships and rayguns, rather than from any lack of literary merit. They were very popular in the 80s. I seem to remember the TV series, with Olympia Dukakis, was quite good from what I remember.My son had to read this for school aged about 14-15, so it's still on a bookcase in the house somewhere though I've never read it myself. I didn't realise that it was "quite rude" "with a lot of drug use and sexual gags." It's a little late to tell me this now! He didn't think much of it. However, he didn't like Of Mice and Men either, another school book. He is still not much of a reader.
I suspect the whole thing of nitpicking and dissecting any book and then having to be tested on it, kills whatever joy anyone might have got out of the book (whatever it is) and makes reading a chore (especially if the kids aren't really good at reading yet due to lack of practice)?I didn't mean that reading those books put my son off reading. He reads crime and war stories, I think. He just didn't think much of those two. I guess there is a bigger issue here, that in this age when it is very difficult to get young boys (especially) and girls to read, that the books they are forced to read at school should be something they will enjoy, but then everyone has different tastes and getting something that an entire class will like must be almost impossible.
My oldest daughter got her joint degree in English literature and teacher training.I suspect the whole thing of nitpicking and dissecting any book and then having to be tested on it, kills whatever joy anyone might have got out of the book (whatever it is) and makes reading a chore (especially if the kids aren't really good at reading yet due to lack of practice)?
That is so very, very sad. Novels are meant to be enjoyed. If you can get something else than just entertainment out of a novel, than great. Or if the novel makes you think. But destroying the joy of reading by dissecting novels is probably why most kids just don't pick up a book if they don't have to.My oldest daughter got her joint degree in English literature and teacher training.
She was, as a school kid, very fond of reading and was often sitting with her nose in a book.
That joy of reading is gone now, for that very reason, as soon as she sets off with a book she can't help starting the analysis of the story structure and looking for the meaning of each sentence.
The algebraist was either my first or second Banks book, I might possibly have read The Player of Games first, but regardless I didn't really have an awareness of how big the Culture was in Banks' work and certainly didn't have it to compare with The Algebraist. I do remember that I don't think I'd ever read anything that had such a complex plot and, for me, rewarding depth packed into a single book (certainly way more than TPoG) and I was forever sold on his writing. That book in particular and all his books in general seem to be written on such a large scale with frequently expertly interwoven threads. I love that in a book and always feel quite disappointed now when I read a book with just one single thread running through it.I finished listening to The Algebraist. It was the first time i'd read it and it was pretty good. I preferred his Culture novels.
I'm not sure what to listen to next. I'm thinking of House of Suns, or Terminal World by Alistair Reynolds.
It certainly warrants a re-listen. There were a lot of character introductions at the beginning, which i struggled to keep track of, and i'm sure i missed some key detail as i couldn't quite reconcile why that Navy Pilot (i forget her name) wanted Sal dead.
I would've enjoyed a sequel to follow up on the AI plot.
It's the same for making musicThat is so very, very sad. Novels are meant to be enjoyed. If you can get something else than just entertainment out of a novel, than great. Or if the novel makes you think. But destroying the joy of reading by dissecting novels is probably why most kids just don't pick up a book if they don't have to.
This is an occupational hazard. When I listen to a sermon I often find myself thinking "Would I have said that, that way?" or "Hm, that's a pretty sketchy insight." But there are times when I am blown away, and I hope that happens to your daughter too from time to time.My oldest daughter got her joint degree in English literature and teacher training.
She was, as a school kid, very fond of reading and was often sitting with her nose in a book.
That joy of reading is gone now, for that very reason, as soon as she sets off with a book she can't help starting the analysis of the story structure and looking for the meaning of each sentence.
Thread starter | Similar threads | Forum | Replies | Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
November Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 177 | ||
November 2022 Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 173 | ||
November 2021 Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 299 | ||
November 2020 Reading Thread | Book Discussion | 198 | ||
T | November 2019 reading thread | Book Discussion | 202 |