"You have two choices." Is that logically impossible?

JunkMonkey said:
I missed it. Enlighten me. I know there's a typo in panel two (missing " before the word 'alternative'). Are you annoyed by my starting a sentence with 'but' perhaps
Click to expand...
I had no idea it was your strip, JunkMonkey - I thought it was pulled off the interweb.
In the first frame it says "But there are some things I know are wrong when hear them", and it should say ".. when I hear them". It seemed ironic to me, given the theme.
 
Bick said:
I had no idea it was your strip, JunkMonkey - I thought it was pulled off the interweb.
In the first frame it says "But there are some things I know are wrong when hear them", and it should say ".. when I hear them". It seemed ironic to me, given the theme.
Click to expand...

Rats! so it does. Amazing that I didn't see that. Thank you.

I lost the I in the line break. I spend so much time struggling to get the shape of the words right in the balloons (it's a juggling act) - stacking them so they're all read in the right order and taking up as small a space as possible. They have to look pleasing and well balanced as well as legible. They have to flow. I read a lot of comics and I can forgive the most scrappy and hurried drawing style if the lettering is good but crappy amateurish lettering will sink the most beautiful art. It's a skill I both admire and struggle with. Sometimes the words loose their meaning and become abstract puzzle pieces.
 
Really when it comes to writing and character choices...

The choice must make sense to the character's character.
It might change as the character changes within the story.
It might be altered by a hierarchy of 'things that are important to the character'; enough to pull them out of character.

And sometimes they might surprise you by taking two choices when it seems normally that one is available. Sometime we are so focused we don't really see that there is more than one way to skin a cat.

Exactly how they choose and what they chose are a part of the story arc and that's probably more important than thinking that they are stuck with only one choice. Whatever the choice...it needs to make sense within the story.
 
My big old dictionary says it’s fine as written:
D9C25314-1A9C-48CE-84DA-F4097EAF5071.jpeg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
B Movies and TV Shows in Which , Had You been a Character You Would Have Made Decidedly Different choices Than They Made . General Film Discussion 24
B What Are Your Choices for Worst Comedy Films Of All Time? General Film Discussion 83
B What are Your Choices for the Best Most Memorable Moments and Scenes in all of Cinema ? General Film Discussion 159
Paul_C Age, and book choices Book Discussion 13
Wiglaf Word choices that suggest class in USA Writing Discussion 34

Similar threads


Back
Top