I thought this might be a useful thread for people to suggest what they're looking for, and others to make suggestions.
I'm looking for something engrossing (which probably means some kind of RPG), with decent gameplay and story. Ideally, I'd like something that isn't in a stereotypical setting: so preferably something other than bog-standard zombie, fantasy and sci-fi settings (something weird like Dune would be cool, though). I've enjoyed the Elder Scrolls and Fallout games, although Morrowind felt like the most original of them by a fair way. In terms of graphics, I don't think my PC would run anything too cutting edge, and I think I'd have trouble with anything made before 2000 or so. Can anyone think of a game that would qualify?