Man, I have not asked this for a long time, but I think this episode deserves an Emmy. Not for the sound or for the music. In fact, be aware that the actor voices almost disappear in this episode, as there is a lot of whispering, hissing, grunting and mumbling. I do applaud the team as they've captured the nature completely, but it's a problem when you don't have subtitles, and the actors voices are so low that you have to turn volume to eleven.
I ask the Emmy to go to the writer Jim Barnes or to the editor Geraldine Iona, as I believe they made the magic happen. For actors I would either give it to Norman Reedus or to Samantha Morton for delivering absolutely terrifying Alpha in the small screen. On the edge is Ryan Hurst, but the thing is there are so stuff that I'm not completely accepting.
It surprised me that Negan's and Alpha romance turned out to be the last for Alpha. I know that the tribe had gathered around their leader at the end, but to be honest, she's walking through the same track as Daryl. I honestly thought he was going to die after Alpha stabbed him in the leg, and left him for the dead. I don't know where he got the strength but I can easily assume that he was tripping in pure adrenaline as soon as Daryl's vision turned grim.
To my memory, Daryl's red vision is the third time in whole history of this season, where they have used the first person view. First one was with Shane at the moment he turned. Second was with Negan using Lucille, and this one really added to the tension. I felt so scared for our beloved ruffian as there was nobody coming to rescue him.
Sure, he hunted down Alpha and it turned out that the shotgun she has been dragging with her is empty, or otherwise I believe she would have blasted Daryl to heaven. What I didn't like about his escape was the zombies, one with roots growing out from him, another showing extensive sea shell infestation.
How is it possible that the man, who has almost composted, and is really turning back to earth is still walking? Those roots hanging out from him indicated that the nature has taken its course. The dead should be dead, but he wasn't and neither was the shell guy. So, the only thing that I can assume that is making to walk is magic. It is beyond the science we can comprehend or even how the dead in the Kirkman's world should behave.
I admire the courage and the patience that Daryl harbours in his soul. He didn't pull the knife until the last minute, and even then, he didn't really scream in agony, even though you can be sure he was in pain... and dying. You cut one of those arteries and you have three minutes left before you have bled to death. I expected Daryl to have already turned, when the night arrived in the petrol station. So I guess he managed to tie his leg and wait for the death to arrive, but instead it was an angel in form of Lydia.
It's easy to understand that she didn't save her mum, when there was nothing Alpha could have offered her. Not to a young lady at the start of her life. But then again she couldn't grant her mum last wish. It was as if she wanted her to realise that the time of the Whisperer's had come to an end and there was nothing for them left in the dead wastes.
Mary said the same thing. The border is unpatrolled and only the horde locations are guarded. Not that she could recognise any other locations then the one that took so many lives. What I don't get is how Beta managed to tunnel his way into the Alexandria and not cause a cave in or even make noises. How did he know where the graveyard was located? Did Alpha tell her?
It is a plot hole, but at the same time it is an amazing plot hole that made Beta to deliver terror into the heart of Rickland. He topped with is performance all the other TWD baddies and even rose above Fear's Filthy Woman. I whooped and praised Judith when she shot Beta through the door, but then I cursed Rick for not teaching the Rule #1 - Always Double Tap. Always!
Jeesus, a scary man comes into the house, and is about to break through the door, what kept Judith from practicing the rule number one? Nothing. I know that she hasn't killed before, but Rosita has and she should have known better to not make sure that the man on floor was not going to turn.
FFS that man had already slaughtered at least half of the Alexandria, before he arrived to the town house. Rosita should have known that instead of trying to escape the giant, monstrous man that had been involved in her husband's death.
I do get that she has a broken heart and Gabriel was right for not taking her out. Still a man of that size, you should make sure that you do follow the rules or you'll risk lives. More lives than they can sacrifice. So I applaud Mary for taking the role and offering her life in the exchange of Alexandrian's souls.
This episode delivers real horror in all forms and it is one of the best TWD has delivered in long time. In the IMDB it is standing at 8.7 at the moment of the writing, but I think the score should be above 9. And that is because the writing is stellar and the whole episode is so, so tensile and full of terror. I think the last time I felt so scared was in the Road to Alexandria. Or in the Fear with the Zombie Twister.