@ctg good video - makes a lot of sense
agreed. the worst thing is, they could have done all that and still had the dead overwhelm the castle, the dothraki die, and all plot points fulfilled. and it would have been much better to watch.That is an excellent analysis and makes sense of the things I thought were wrong but didn't have enough knowledge to explain why. I'm no military strategist, but even I thought I could have done better. The plan he outlines should have been thought up by Tyrion rather than hiding in the crypt and the civilians should have been building the earthworks.