Rejoice, A Knife to the Heart by Steven Erikson

Werthead

Lemming of Discord
Joined
Jun 4, 2006
Messages
2,188
Rejoice, a Knife to the Heart by Steven Erikson

A Canadian science fiction writer is abducted by a UFO from the streets of Victoria, British Columbia. The world shrugs and dismisses it as a social media hoax. Days later, mysterious forcefields start appearing around wilderness areas in danger of human encroachment. Fracking sites are cut off, animal migratory routes disrupted by human civilisation restored and fishing boats are unable to cast their nets. Then people find themselves being forcibly prevented from hurting one another. An Intervention has taken place.

Far above the Earth, an alien presence has arrived. Its mission is to repair and restore the biosphere of the planet but it is conflicted over what to do about humanity, who have been abject failures in their role as custodian of the planet's welfare. Fortunately, they have another job in mind for humanity, one that merely requires them to completely transform the very paradigm of their existence, forever...

Steven Erikson is best-known in genre circles for his Malazan Book of the Fallen fantasy sequence, consisting of ten brick-thick novels packed with battles, sorcery, comedy, tragedy, drama and musings on compassion, morality and ethics. The Malazan series is both an epic fantasy and an inverted interrogation of epic fantasy. His forays outside the field into science fiction have been less noteworthy, consisting of three Star Trek pastiches and a post-apocalyptic novella.

Rejoice, a Knife to the Heart is therefore his first serious, full-length science fiction novel and it's probably going to take people by surprise. It's relatively short (400 pages of quite large type), focused and a bit of a throwback to SF's golden age, consisting of story development through sequences of conversations between core characters. It feels like something Clarke or Asimov would have written in the 1950s, except with far superior character development.

Integral to the story is the fact that people can no longer hurt or kill one another, which means that the good old genre stand-bys - shoot-outs, nukes, battles, chases, character deaths - are unavailable to the author. This feels like a challenge Erikson has set out to himself and he meets with relish. The wit and erudition of the Malazan series is still present here, but seriously pared back to more human and witty levels. Rejoice, a Knife to the Heart is, surprisingly, Erikson's most approachable and accessible novel to date.

It's a novel that asks big questions about the future of humanity and what our fate will be, self-destruction (either in war or from societal collapse resulting from environmental disaster, dwindling resources or simple exhaustion of the human spirit) or enlightenment, discovering means of abolishing scarcity and moving into a truly utopian existence, and how that will impact on a species conditioned by centuries of exposure to free-market capitalism. To that end, those expecting "Malazan, but in space," (at least in terms of sheer scale) will be disappointed. But those up for a stimulating, question-raising, intelligent SF novel which explores ideas of scarcity, postcapitalism, paradigm shifts, fake news, populism, climate change, Big Dumb Objects and environmentalism, all done in a concise manner, this book is for you.

Challenges abound in the novel, most notably how to build tension when it's literally impossible to have any kind of military confrontation or action resulting in injury or death. Erikson does this with a great philosophical debate: the mysterious aliens spare humanity for a specific reason, because there's something we can do they cannot, and this central mystery is gently teased out over the course of the book in a manner that's compelling. It's also not quite resolved in the space of this one novel: sequels are not strictly necessary, but would be welcome to explore some of the mysteries left unexplained in this book.

This is also a novel which may be tapping SF's golden age, but it's also a very timely novel. There's nods to the #metoo movement and almost all of the movers and shakers in the story are based on real people. It's pretty obvious which US President the fictional one is based on, and spotting the fictional equivalents of the Koch Brothers, Elon Musk and Rupert Murdoch is amusing. The book also has a very human side, and the key theme of the Malazan series - compassion and empathy - rears its head here as well. There's also a few touching tributes to SF authors who have passed away in the novel, which may make a few lower lips quiver.

Rejoice, a Knife to the Heart (****) is going to be a divisive book, I feel. I suspect some will be bored by a novel which consists almost entirely of conversations between people without a laser gun battle in sight (there are a couple of small explosions though), but for those who read SF for ideas, for intelligent observations on the world around us and explorations of what humanity could be if it could throw off the shackles of inequality and exploitation, this is a fascinating work. It will be published in the UK and USA on 18 October 2018.
 
Thank you, @Werthead for this review. Sounds like the kind of story I love to read and is on my list now.
 
Interesting, I've never read any of his fantasy, but might give this a try. Though I confess I am starting to find the rather well worn tope of aliens appearing and saving humanity (and the Earth biosphere) from themselves a bit tedious. But a new respected author taking on a serious SF novel is always worth a look.
 
Though I confess I am starting to find the rather well worn tope of aliens appearing and saving humanity (and the Earth biosphere) from themselves a bit tedious.
Agreed, it is getting a bit old. But one might not be considered a complete misanthrope if one thought that nothing else is gonna save us. A deus ex machina instead of divine intervention if you will. ;)

I watched the news today, oh boy ...
 
Agreed, it is getting a bit old. But one might not be considered a complete misanthrope if one thought that nothing else is gonna save us. A deus ex machina instead of divine intervention if you will. ;)

I watched the news today, oh boy ...

Hm, I think what we all need to do is stop hoping that Aliens from outer space or some backwater dimension are going magically appear on the scene and save us from ourselves. The Monitors tried that in 1969 and look where that got them.:whistle::D
 
Sorry @Werthead - " I suspect some will be bored by a novel which consists almost entirely of conversations between people" - I'm afraid I am that person. :(

I dropped out of fantasy reading some years ago before I’d ever got around to reading Erikson’s famous Malazan books. But I have always continued in my love of science fiction so, when an SF book from Erikson appeared a few years ago, I figured I ought to try it. Bad mistake!

I’m afraid I found this an appalling novel, at least the first 170 pages, after which I gave up. This is simply Erikson venting his views on the environment on an unsuspecting public. To any aspiring authors this book has to be one of the best demonstrations of how to tell and never show. In all those pages there might, if I’m being generous, be a dozen or so pages where anything actually happens, rather than events being discussed, reported on in news reports or newspapers (one chapter is literally just a series of fictional articles from different newspapers) or vlogs, or just being described in bland prose. When that telling wasn’t going one the reader is subjected to endless conversations between an alien AI and our (presumably as I didn’t read far enough to be sure) hero.

These conversations were just an opportunity for Erikson to pontificate about how badly humans have treated the planet, the ecology, the animals and each other. Now, as it happens, I do agree with most of what he has to say, it’s just that there’s nothing new being presented it’s all been previously expounded at enormous length more times than I can count. Which doesn’t make it irrelevant, just insufficient to be virtually the sole basis of a book. Had it been more in the background with a half decent story worked around it I would not have minded. But as it is it just felt utterly self-indulgent and I’m afraid I just don’t need Erikson to give validation to my own environmental opinions when plenty of scientist have already done so many times over. Along the way I was also irritated by the way he also chucks in one or two conspiracy theories that will make the tinfoil-hat brigade ecstatic, I’m sure.

I’m sorry but, whilst I don’t mind a certain amount of proselytising and philosophising in my fictional reading, indeed I actively enjoy it, but I do want a good story as well. And a bunch of benevolent aliens arriving and forcing all humans to be nice to each other and their planet using technologies so advanced as to be magic, just doesn’t cut it for me. It’s already been done far too often and much more competently.

1/5 stars
 

Similar threads


Back
Top