We already had Matt Smith.
More seriously, I still think that William Hartnell to Patrick Troughton was the biggest change in age and character and totally unexpected.
The 13th Doctor Reveal Thread
- Thread starter HoopyFrood
- Start date
More seriously, I still think that William Hartnell to Patrick Troughton was the biggest change in age and character and totally unexpected.
I thought it was quite obvious, but many Nurses aren't female either. Anyone using that phrase, even as a joke, just appeared ignorant. Which is why @TheDustyZebra "defenders" seemed totally unnecessary.
I agree with Dave, I thought it would be a storm in a teacup for a few days, disappear then resurface before the Christmas episode. Don't people have better things too discuss?
My prediction, she will be the most popular Dr since Tom Baker, the story lines will improve and everyone will wonder why there was so much fuss.
My prediction, she will be the most popular Dr since Tom Baker, the story lines will improve and everyone will wonder why there was so much fuss.
And my dad was a nurse.
Danny McG
"Uroshnor!"
I remember watching some Western, made in the fifties I would imagine from hairstyles etc of the cast.
The 'comedy' part of the plot was one of the protagonists was a man but also a nurse!
The 'comedy' part of the plot was one of the protagonists was a man but also a nurse!
Cathbad
Level 30 Geek Master
...and some nurses aren't female.
Cathbad
Level 30 Geek Master
Overread
Searching for a flower
My impression is that we don't have much sci-fi that's current at present to talk about. The only other big fantasy/scifi is Song of Ice and Fire. Otherwise there isn't that much out there at present; so its no surprise that Dr. Who is getting so much attention. Plus its reboot has netted a huge casual/not geek fanbase which means way more people to talk about and keep things going.
For most people this is also a pretty big change. It's up there with if they decided that the Tardis was going to change shape to reflect a more modern era (A red phone booth with the windows blacked out with adverts of various kinds)
MemoryTale
Good with a stick
Yes but that was some decades ago. That was before my time, but I have read that there was an equal amount of furor back then. But of course Troughton made the role his own, and he won fans over. Thus regeneration is normalised, and the argument had already been won by the time Pertwee, Baker et al came around. If Jodie Whittaker can do the same, then the second female Doctor will be much more accepted.
I hope.
Cathbad
Level 30 Geek Master
Fact is, if they fixed the TARDIS, it would be able to change forms! (Then again, it would remove the show's main icon and longest standing joke.)
Vladd67
Stake Holder
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2007
- Messages
- 4,089
And that all nurses aren't female, Rory from Dr Who springs to mind.
MemoryTale
Good with a stick
And Strax. Mustn't forget Strax or he may be forced to obliterate us on the field of battle
Vladd67
Stake Holder
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2007
- Messages
- 4,089
I think when Peter Davidson was The Doctor the Chameleon circuit was briefly fixed but for some reason, negative fan reaction perhaps, it broke again.
Mr Orange
Rhubarb rhubarb rhubarb...
just to add my 2c to the matter, with the gender fluidity shown already in the time lords, i really don't see a problem with a female doctor. "male" time lords can regenerate as "female", end of. you can argue about the beeb's reasons for making the change, but there doesn't need to be any reason for it within the world of the doctor.
let's hope for some good writing as well.
let's hope for some good writing as well.
MemoryTale
Good with a stick
That was a Colin Baker episode if memory serves, and he didn't properly fix it - its forms were still wildly inappropriate. I'm not sure if it was negative fan reaction, or just the BBC didn't want to keep finding new props for what was essentially a visual gag.
I seem to remember it being something else in the scrapyard in "Remembrance of the Daleks" but don't quote me. Edit: No, not sure why I thought that.
The Master's TARDIS was often different things. Edit: see here Other TARDISes
I suspect that the real reason is that because it hasn't changed it has become something of a Dr. Who symbol and trade mark. The BBC make a huge amount of money internationally from the licensed merchandise of toys and such. You aren't likely to throw away that kind of money. It would be like Jedi no longer using light-sabres or a Star Trek Federation ship without two nacelles.
Last edited:
Danny McG
"Uroshnor!"
Vladd67
Stake Holder
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2007
- Messages
- 4,089
I seem to remember it being something else in the scrapyard in "Remembrance of the Daleks" but don't quote me. Edit: No, not sure why I thought that.
The Master's TARDIS was often different things. Edit: see here Other TARDISes
I suspect that the real reason is that because it hasn't changed it has become something of a Dr. Who symbol and trade mark. The BBC make a huge amount of money internationally from the licensed merchandise of toys and such. You aren't likely to throw away that kind of money. It would be like Jedi no longer using light-sabres or a Star Trek Federation ship without two nacelles.
Yes, it was the organ that I was thinking of. So, it was the Colin Baker episode, thanks.
The Master's TARDIS was a grandfather clock and a Doric pillar.
The Master's TARDIS was a grandfather clock and a Doric pillar.
| Thread starter | Similar threads | Forum | Replies | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Birmingham 13th October. | Conventions and Events | 0 | |
|
The 13th Vote - now released on ebook! | Promotions | 11 | |
|
|
The 13th Vote : mark two | Critiques | 19 | |
|
|
The 13th Vote | Critiques | 13 | |
|
First look at the 13th Doctors costume... | Doctor Who | 44 |