Well it’s better than Batman vs Superman. But a back massage with a Hedgehog covered in dog jobbies is better than Batman Vs Superman. One thing they do have in common (Along with Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, The Star Wars Prequels, Star Trek into Darkens, Age of Ultron, The Hobbit trilogy, Steven Moffat’s Doctor Who and to a lesser extent The Force Awakens) is that they sacrifice good storytelling to fan service and world building (after Fant4stic managed to get I everything about the source material wrong I suspect Fox panicked and flipped to the opposite extreme with this movie).
Days of Future Past was able to whether its continuity overload by focusing very clearly on four well developed protagonists, Charles, Erik, Raven and Wolverine. Apocalypse by contrast never settles on a clear lead as it’s so busy trying to cram in and introduce so many characters. The film derails its own narrative for a good 20 minutes simply to reboot Wolverine’s origins.
Some intriguing threads emerge such as a surprisingly compelling turn by Sophie Turner as Jean Grey but it’s mostly lost in the muddle. Alex’s death scene should have been a major emotional moment but it’s undermined by the fact he gets himself killed through his own bumbling and the director’s choice to focus on a fan pleasing re-tread of Quicksilver’s fan pleasing slo mo antics kill any drama they could have gotten out of it.
It also tries to paint itself as a touching redemption story for Erik when really it makes him into an irredeemable arse. By the end of the film he’s murdered more people than Apocalypse himself but Charles is still happy to pal around with him like the worse he’d done was speed through a red light.
This certainly isn’t helped by the fact that Magneto’s tragic bereavement of the week wasn’t even deliberate this time (the hilariously contrived scene of a guard accidentally killing his family with a bow and arrow because some finches distracted him felt more like Monty Python than Greek tragedy) yet he sees it as a perfectly good excuse to go on yet another murder spree. Not only does this make him irredeemable but by extension makes Charles’s willingness to let him wander free to kill again extremely suspect.