Mr B.S not getting the love?

Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
7
#1
Hello all!

I just joined Chronicles as an aspiring author and lifetime fan. Although I was a little surprised that Brandon Sanderson has had no recent threads and as such I thought I could perhaps entice some discussion.

As most people I only discovered him when I completed the Wheel of Time series but since then I have sought out and read almost all his work.

With the second part (third and fourth books) of his Stormlight series now enjoying a well deserved rest upon my bookshelf I found myself asking is he the best fantasy author currently out there?

What really inspires me is that he has produced a range of novels and series which all have a unique take on magic systems. Is there another author out there that can say the same? (Please enlighten me)
 

Jo Zebedee

Aliens vs Belfast.
Joined
Oct 5, 2011
Messages
15,697
Location
blah - flags. So many flags.
#2
Hello all!

I just joined Chronicles as an aspiring author and lifetime fan. Although I was a little surprised that Brandon Sanderson has had no recent threads and as such I thought I could perhaps entice some discussion.

As most people I only discovered him when I completed the Wheel of Time series but since then I have sought out and read almost all his work.

With the second part (third and fourth books) of his Stormlight series now enjoying a well deserved rest upon my bookshelf I found myself asking is he the best fantasy author currently out there?

What really inspires me is that he has produced a range of novels and series which all have a unique take on magic systems. Is there another author out there that can say the same? (Please enlighten me)
Shall I play devil's advocate. Now, I quite like Sanderson, but I don't think he's close to the best fantasy author out there (although, pushed into a corner, I'd say that's down to taste - I adore Bujold, many don't....)

Nor do I think he's one of the most original - his magic systems are usually pretty cool, but many of his world's are twists on classic fantasy worlds.

So, nice, escapist author who churns out a serious work load (I totally admire his work ethic) but, for me, lacks depth and, perhaps, the level of emotional engagement that makes me a gibbering wreck of a reader (which I quite enjoy being....)
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
7
#3
Shall I play devil's advocate. Now, I quite like Sanderson, but I don't think he's close to the best fantasy author out there (although, pushed into a corner, I'd say that's down to taste - I adore Bujold, many don't....)

Nor do I think he's one of the most original - his magic systems are usually pretty cool, but many of his world's are twists on classic fantasy worlds.

So, nice, escapist author who churns out a serious work load (I totally admire his work ethic) but, for me, lacks depth and, perhaps, the level of emotional engagement that makes me a gibbering wreck of a reader (which I quite enjoy being....)
I am ashamed to say I haven't read anything from Bujold, I am a little too old fashioned and still buy most of my books from the high street where I have never seen her works being sold. Would you advise starting with her fantasy or sci-fi?

Better be careful I don't go completely off the topic of Brandon Sanderson...

In terms of the fantasy world what I think he brings to the table is the intricate detail. In particular in the Stormlight novels I love how we are given impressions of the fashion and culture of the people of each land

I must admit that he doesn't typically go down the route of heavy emotional engagement, especially in terms of a love relationship between characters. However I actually find it quite refreshing as I have read too many books where you can see an author tries too hard to add a realistic love interest. Don't get me wrong I'm not against it, I suppose I just feel the market is saturated with it.
 

Jo Zebedee

Aliens vs Belfast.
Joined
Oct 5, 2011
Messages
15,697
Location
blah - flags. So many flags.
#4
I prefer Bujold's sf, but I'm a sf kind of gal, mainly. Her fantasy is also good, and I have plans to read more than I currently have. :)

Actually, my problem isn't that he doesn't go down the romantic/relationship angle, but that I find it unconvincing when he does. Vim's love interest, for instance, is a drip* and, for me, I struggled to engage with him. If relationships happen, we should be able to see why.

* I'm not opinionated. Oh, no, not me ;) :)
 

Brian G Turner

Fantasist & Futurist
Staff member
Joined
Nov 23, 2002
Messages
21,013
Location
Highlands
#5
Welcome to chronicles, rmaxix! And I'm also surprised that we don't get more discussions on Brandon Sanderson's work - clearly his output is phenomenal. However, you're more than welcome to dig up old threads in the Brandon Sanderson section to get discussions going again - I'm sure once you reply to one or two, more people will join in with you. :)
 

thaddeus6th

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2007
Messages
5,916
Location
UK, Yorkshire
#6
Like others, I admire (and am jealous of) his productivity.

I've just begun Words of Radiance, at last. Once I'm done I'll probably check for a thread on that (don't want any spoilers before then).
 

Similar threads

Top