Percy Jackson & The Lightning Thief (2010), and The Secret of Moonacre (2009)

Anthony G Williams

Greybeard
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
1,225
Location
UK
Something of a change from my usual fare, but perhaps appropriate for the holiday season: a couple of films aimed at younger viewers.

Percy Jackson & The Lightning Thief (aso known as Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief) is loosely based on the first of a series of novels by Rick Riordan. It concerns a 17-year old boy (played by Logan Lerman) in present-day USA who suddenly finds himself under supernatural attack, and discovers not only that his previously unknown father was Poseidon, the God of the Sea, but that he is suspected of stealing Zeus' greatest weapon, the lightning bolt. If the bolt is not returned, there will be war among the gods which would lead to devastation on Earth.

Percy reaches safety at a special camp in rural USA established to train demigods like him; the offspring of relationships between gods and humans. There he discovers some of his magical abilities and, with two companions, sets off on a quest to find the bolt and rescue his mother, who is being held hostage by Hades, the God of the Underworld. Many spectacular adventures ensue before the quest is over.

There is a strong cast, including Uma Thurman, Sean Bean, Pierce Brosnan and Catherine Keener. The story rolls along well enough, mixing mystery, excitement and humour with some dramatic CGI, and will probably appeal to teenage fans of the Harry Potter films.

----------------

The Secret of Moonacre is based on a children's fantasy novel, The Little White Horse by Elizabeth Goudge, first published in 1946. It is set in the 1840s and concerns a teenage girl, Maria Merryweather (Dakota Blue Richards, who played the lead character in The Golden Compass) who is orphaned and sent to live with her taciturn uncle Sir Benjamin Merryweather (Ioan Gruffud) in his remote country estate, Moonacre Manor. There she discovers that the Merryweathers have had a generations-long vendetta against their nearest neighbours, the De Noir family, in which magic was involved. She gradually learns that she has a pivotal role to play in ending both the vendetta and also an ancient curse which threatens to destroy everything in the valley.

The cast of this film is strong too (it also includes Juliet Stevenson in a comic turn, Tim Curry and Natascha McElhone) and the production excellent - it’s a visual pleasure. The story is rather bland with a schmaltzy ending and it didn't grip me, which is perhaps no surprise since I would assume that its target audience is young girls (who I guess will probably love it), but it was painless to watch.

(An extract from my SFF blog: http://sciencefictionfantasy.blogspot.co.uk/)
 

Riddick

Active Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2012
Messages
27
That's a nice review of these two movies. I've never seen Percy Jackson and was curious as to what it was about, like in depth. I knew the basic story.

Thanks for sharing these :)
 

Teresa Edgerton

Goblin Princess
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Nov 1, 2004
Messages
15,062
Location
California
For me, The Secret of Moonacre was not painless to watch. I've known and loved the book for years, and while I understand that books and movies are two different things, they changed most of the main characters so that they would have been unrecognizable if not for the names, and while I can see why they bumped up the magic, if they wanted something more magical, why not choose another book to film, or (gasp) come up with an original script?

It was pleasing to the eye, however.
 

Anthony G Williams

Greybeard
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
1,225
Location
UK
I can entirely understand your reaction, Teresa. As a general rule I find it is almost always better to watch the film version of a book before I read the book. That way, I am far less likely to be disappointed by the film.
 

Reivax26

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2009
Messages
276
Location
Granite Falls North Carolina
The movie for Lightning Thief does not compare to the novel. I have read all of the Percy Jackson novels and I am really hoping that the 2nd movie which comes out next year is going to follow the 2nd book a lot closer than its predecessor did.
 

Juliana

Juliana Spink Mills. "No capes!"
Supporter
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
5,051
Location
Connecticut, USA
The movie for Lightning Thief does not compare to the novel. I have read all of the Percy Jackson novels and I am really hoping that the 2nd movie which comes out next year is going to follow the 2nd book a lot closer than its predecessor did.

Agreed. I watched the movie before I read the novels and enjoyed it. Then I read the book... Big fan of Rick's stories!! And the film version makes some very unecessary changes to the original.
 

Similar threads


Top