The Dragon Masters by Jack Vance

Anthony G Williams

Greybeard
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
1,225
Location
UK
Jack Vance was one of the giants of my early SFF reading and is still around today. His last novel (to date) was published in 2004, some 54 years after the first. In between came some forty SFF novels, plus novellas and some mystery stories. He won several major awards, one of them - the Hugo in 1963 - for The Dragon Masters. This was one of my recommendations for the Classic Science Fiction discussion group, as I felt that such an influential author needed an airing and I was looking forward to re-reading his work after a long absence.

The most obvious feature of the book is its length: at just over 120 pages it is barely a novella in modern terms. Even by the standards of the 1960s this is a bit short (something nearer 200 pages being more typical then) , but that doesn't mean it is lacking in ideas. In fact, novels from this period tended to be all about ideas, with characterisation and detailed world-building receiving sketchy treatment. That doesn't make them worse than modern doorstops, just different, with the added benefit that they can be polished off in a session or two so even if they're not much good, you haven't wasted a lot of time on them. In contrast, I need to wind myself up to grappling with a huge modern tome, and have to feel mentally fit and fresh before I start. Also, I frequently don't finish them; if they're going to monopolise so much of my time, they'd better be good. I wrote about book length in more detail in this web article: The Length of SF Novels .

No problems of this sort with The Dragon Masters. The reader is plunged straight into the action, in the form of a strange intruder breaking in to the private apartment of Joaz Banbeck, hereditary leader of the small community of Banbeck Vale on the sparsely populated planet of Aerlith. The intruder is a sacerdote, one of a secretive group of contemplative humans who live a separate existence in deep caverns in the mountains which border the Vale. Joaz investigates the sacerdotes to find out what is going on, and learns that they have developed a mysterious but powerful weapon. He is interested in this because not only is he facing a challenge from his territorially expansive neighbours in Happy Valley, he is worried that the gradual brightening of star Coralyne may indicate the possible return of the grephs (the "dragons" of the title); a lizard-like race with technology - including spaceships - far more advanced than the humans, and whose previous destructive visits have been to capture humans for slaves and breeding stock.

Vance then jumps back to the past with a chapter set in the time of the last greph attack. The grephs subjected their human stock to selective breeding, producing a variety of specialised types differing considerably in size and characteristics (much as we do with dogs). The humans of Aerlith were able to capture some of the grephs and over the intervening years also bred them - for internecine warfare, producing breeds with names such as Termagants, Fiends, Murderers, Juggers and Blue Horrors.

The plot follows the fortunes of Joaz as he juggles the problems of invasion from his neighbour, greph attack, and the enigmatic sacerdotes.

How does this award-winner stand up today? Not too well in terms of literary quality, but the fresh and imaginative plot, the selective breeding of humans and dragons, and the strange culture which results on Aerlith, all have their appeal. Definitely worth the couple of hours needed to read.

(An extract from my SFF blog)
 

Fried Egg

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2006
Messages
3,496
The high accalim of this novel(la) mysterfied me some what. One of the weaker of his books that I have read. Not a bad read by any means though.
 

Connavar

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
8,411
I think it won because of the idea Dragon Masters, i dont think its near one of the best SF stories by Jack Vance literary quality wise. Storywise very good but literary wise its not the usual Vance quality.

The Miracle Workers,The Last Castle,several other similar stories are much stronger.

Anthony have you re-read other Vance ,stories,novels you read early one ?

I have read 20-30 books of him in the last 3 years and he is the best SF,fantasy author i have read and i have read alot of the ones seen as the best.

A prose stylist, a masterful world builder,social sf writer. His stories age so well to me, i dont even remember they were written 50,40 years ago most of them.
 

Anthony G Williams

Greybeard
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
1,225
Location
UK
I remember 'The Last Castle' and 'The Languages of Pao' (I still have the latter) and I also have 'Star King' and 'The Blue World', plus a more recent work: 'Mask: Thaery', but I don't recall what the last three are about.
 

Connavar

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
8,411
I remember 'The Last Castle' and 'The Languages of Pao' (I still have the latter) and I also have 'Star King' and 'The Blue World', plus a more recent work: 'Mask: Thaery', but I don't recall what the last three are about.
So you have read Star King and Blue World ? Star King is the start of my fav SF series. Star King was good but The Killing Machine,The Palace of Love is better. Mask: Thaery i got second hand from other Vance fan but currently im reading him by publication order. I have read his 40s,50s stories and im on his 60s novels,short stories,novellas.

If you want to read more Vance today that series i think you would like. The details of world building,original worlds is why its the only space opera series i like. Dragon Masters i must say its the only story of his i have read where the world building,characters was so sketchy for a novella or 200 page novels of his.

Like George RR Martin says in the introduction in Jack Vance Treasury if you want original worlds and even bizzare ones Vance is the way to go. Frankly thats why i read him so often, his literary talents,storytelling,prose style is just a bonus ;)
 
Top