FanFic Excerpt - Have I Improved?

Status
Not open for further replies.

TTM

Time Travelling Mechanic
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
Messages
18
Hello all :)

A few months back I submitted an excerpt of my Naruto FanFic here for critique, and I recieved many points and suggestions (I kinda entered a brick, without paragraph spacing and the like :p)

Since then I left these boards, bearing the lessons I learned and determined to improve myself.

Now I have returned with new work to be critiqued again, and to see if I have improved any.

I would like to thank all who read my last entry, whether you reviewed and made suggestions or not, and I also would like to thank you for taking the time with a FanFic writer who has dreams of becoming a novel writer someday. Cheers everyone :)


**********

“Okay Kokinshu-niisan, the traps are set. You and Noko get some sleep. Sobi and I will take the first watch. Hai?”

Grateful that he would be able to get two or three hours rest the Samurai merely nodded as he sat down on a battered stool, his loyal Nin-dog yawning and laying next to the dusty chair, resting a weary head on its two front paws.

Tanka and her scarred companion took up a position in the gutted corner booth of the old tea house where Kokinshu had decided they would hole up for a few hours.
The old wooden floorboards were warped unevenly from periodic exposure to the elements through the broken front windows and in places were fractured or broken, shards of the shattered pane gathering in the breaks and recessions.
The faded drywall across from the counter where the white-clad Samurai now sat was punctuated with two rusting kunai, and below these the floor was stained with old blood spilt long ago.
Time as of yet had been unable to erase the blotted circle, nor the drag lines which led into the empty backroom, snow intruding in the darkness by way of a fracture in the deteriorated building’s ceiling.
Despite the fresh air circulating through the tea house’s front room the building gave off the musty smell of dust and decay.

But none of the present Ninja were about to complain, dog or person. All were tired and had depleted their chakra greatly.
That said, the results of their combined skill were clear. Between them they had fourteen of the stone tokens, mostly a product of the successful defence of Tanka’s territory, a small square which had featured a frozen fountain, soon after finding one another in the near blizzard conditions outside.
Once it had been impossible to defend the plaza any longer they had set fire to all of the burnable structures and left, fighting their way along the outskirts. Just as all three Tokugawa Chunin had agreed upon arrival.

Looking across the filthy room Kokinshu frowned. It was the second evening and they still hadn’t met up with Kyoka.
Hopefully he hasn’t deviated from the plan, and gone into the center of town he thought, annoyed at the possibility.
That was where the fighting was thickest. Both Kokinshu and Tanka had viewed the regions surrounding the base of the tower earlier in the day, from the mantle of a rusted rooftop water tower.
Surrounding the base were obvious signs of battle. Smoking craters visible through the falling snow, the scent of blood mixing with the wet odour of the city in the wind.
And the bodies.
Whole teams of dead Ninja lay around the tower’s base, their dogs alongside them in a grotesque parody of loyalty after death, crimson pools staining the purity of the white snow.

The fools had fallen into the first trap of Murasaka: trying to claim the tower as their own territory.

There was no question: anyone who controlled the tower had a massive advantage. The entire arena was visible from its sheltered stone eaves, and one could sit back and wait for others to launch an assault.
But attempting to take this particular high ground was folly.
From the icicle draped water tower both Kokinshu and Tanka had seen that the architectural monolith had no doors on the ground floor, and no landings until well over halfway up the structure. Entry was going to be almost impossible during these three days.
Even if you ran up the tower’s side, you would stand out like August fire during your ascent, and could only expect to be picked off from afar by Ninja waiting for such recklessness and idiocy.

Sighing at the apparent stupidity of some of the lower born entrants Kokinshu brought his mind back to the matter at hand, pulling his right arm and shoulder out of his kimono before wiping a thick layer of greasy dust off the counter where he had seated himself and drawing a small tied pouch off his sash.

Wherever he was, Kyoka would be leaving a trail of blood across this city.
While Kokinshu had no problem whatsoever killing a downed opponent to spare them the shame of failure and to ensure they never became a recurrent nuisance, for Kyoka it was never a choice NOT to kill a defeated opponent, the idea of revelling in the taking of a life too good to pass up.
The man had no self control, and if it wasn’t for the insistence of Kokinshu’s uncle, currently acting as regent of the Tokugawa clan, he would have left him in the asylum, alone with his paranoia and madness.
The defeat of the enemies is one thing. But Kyoka was a loose cannon: his lust for blood and killing was never slaked, and if Kokinshu wasn’t there to direct him he would likely follow his thirst to an untimely demise.
Assuming he didn’t take either Kokinshu or Tanka down to Hell with him.

“Here Tanka-san, eat this. I prepared it before we came so it’s fresh.” Kokinshu said, throwing a sky blue pill over the broken and pitted floorboards to his cousin, who grunted in thanks before biting it in two and handing half to Sobi before both swallowed, the rust coloured dog crunching it twice.

Looking out the jagged remnants of snow frosted panes of glass toward the front of the secluded arcade Tanka had to smile to herself. The taste of wild berries lingered still. Her cousin really was a man of many talents.
She had known him to travel out into the wilderness of the Land of Grass by himself to gather the ingredients for these blue soldier pills, and then slave tirelessly over his personal alchemical bench for hours, even days, until the finished product met his extraordinarily high standards.

Slowly feeling her pathways relaxing as her chakra well filled once more she spoke to her cousin, neither her nor Sobi averting their attention from the covered alleyway outside, snow banking at it’s entrance.
“Kokinshu-niisan. Is it true that after you kill the Inuzuka that you will assume lordship of our clan?”

Kokinshu did not respond for a moment, the question lingering in the stale air of the broken tea house as the samurai thought on the question, putting his arm back through his white right sleeve after brushing the sticky dust off as best as he could so as not to stain the expensive material.
As Tanka began to think he would not answer Kokinshu stood leisurely, tying the pouch back onto his belt.

“That question has weighed long on my mind, Tanka-san. To set my father’s ghost to rest has always been my goal, first and foremost. I suppose once I go home I will challenge my uncle to a sword fight, and if I am able to defeat him I think I will be capable of leading our clan to a better future, as my father would have wanted.” The white-clad Ninja said thoughtfully before turning back towards the counter, seeing Noko asleep after having eaten her half of his own blue pill.

“But… that’s not the only reason you want to kill Inuzuka, is it?” Tanka said delicately, testing the waters on the subject she really wanted to discuss.

Kokinshu glanced at her sidewards along the counter, taking in the dark Miko before him. A few loose snowflakes hung in her black hair, Tanka too lazy to shake them loose.
He had known that Tanka of all people would have noticed. She did not wear the clothes of a shrine maiden just as a fashion statement. Her knowledge of spiritual matters was vast, and while not on mission many came to her for help with purifying the sites of deaths and suicides.

“I thought you noticed it.” He replied bluntly as Sobi pricked his ears to listen above a gust of wind which howled past the entrance of the arcade, snow whirling down the dark alleyway and collecting with the old trash.

Tanka spoke with a note of interest in her voice, never once ceasing her surveillance of the outside world.
“He has a dark presence within him. It feels to me like it has only recently made itself known, but already I can sense that this prescence has deep roots seeded in Inuzuka’s very soul.”
After watching an icicle fall into the courtyard and shatter into a sea of diamonds on white velvet with a muffled thump, she continued.
“This… darkness, it seems more like an advisor than a puppeteer, but whatever it is the taint is strong. Maybe too strong. If he is allowed to live it may take control of him.”

She turned away from the frosty window remnants for a moment, her long dark hair swaying as she looked at Kokinshu, a black eyebrow raised in interest.
“It seems your uncle was right. There is some kind of evil in that clan. Almost as if the Inuzuka know Death well, like an old friend or a close confidante. It is a good thing we’re going to put him down.”

Tanka turned her attention to the arcade once more, brushing some dust from her black sleeve.
“You introduce me to the most interesting people, Kokinshu-niisan. Now get some rest. Kyoka-san is still out there, and the sooner we find him the better.”

**********

Thanks again for reading guys, and especially for your help previously.

And if you submit work for critique too, I'll be reviewing on here for a while :)
 
Hi TTM.

I've never read any fanfic, and I also know nothing of the subject matter you are writing about, but I'll try to give some comments on the writing, which is all that matters.

Overall I think it is well-written, you are definitely a writer.

I had a hard time following some of the characters. I think you are telling us about the aftermath of a battle, correct?

That said, I think some of your sentences are too long. Here's an example:

Kokinshu did not respond for a moment, the question lingering in the stale air of the broken tea house as the samurai thought on the question, putting his arm back through his white right sleeve after brushing the sticky dust off as best as he could so as not to stain the expensive material.


For my tastes, there is too much going on here. Perhaps this may better describe the situation:

Kokinshu did not respond for a moment. The question lingered in the stale air of the broken tea house as he continued to think. After brushing the sticky dust off his (robe?) he put his arm back through the white sleeve so as not to stain the expensive material.
(Or something like this.)

I made it less passive: "continued to think" as opposed to "thought on the question." This puts the reader more in the moment of what your characters are experiencing.

But, like I said, some of the wordier passages aside, I think you definitely have talent and would encourage to keep writing!
 
Same here, also not really into Naruto. (I do know Japanese (culture/history), kokinshu and Tanka as names for example: very funny)
And although I can understand people who make fanfiction, I never really felt the need myself. I guess it's the difference between drawing mickey mouse in different positions and creating your own character in different positions.

The trouble is that I have difficulty picturing people and happenings in this fanfic, because I have never seen the series. I know no background, I know not the appearance of characters. While fanfiction might lead you to writing more, which is never a bad idea, it will never teach you how to build up a character, because characters have already been created. It will never teach you how to create an atmosphere, since that has already been done.

All I can comment on is the general idea (which is okay) and spelling and grammar (which I'm so bad at that I won't even try).

If you want to become a novel writer, then I'd suggest you start to write pieces that include all aspects of novel writing, rather than acting in a fancfic world, where the characters have been sculpt and the world and environment has been settled for you.

Sorry for my preaching.:eek: If you enjoy writing fanfiction then go on, why not, but when you want to shift to writing your own stuff, don't forget character building and environment.:)
 
Hey guys, thanks for reviewing :D

Balthazar: Thanks for the encouragement.

I do know that sometimes I write epic long sentences and that I should work on breaking them where I can, and thanks for your suggestion. It makes sense.

Cheers mate :)

ScalemX: I actually whole-heartedly agree with you.

I understand and fully appreciate that with a FanFic one does not develop their ability to create original settings and interesting characters of their own.

So you may be surprised to learn that everything in this excerpt is my own.

The competition they are embroiled in, the city they are fighting within, are my creations. As are Kokinshu and Kyoka, as well as their Nin-dogs.

The subject of the Nin-dog is not discussed at all within the series (except to point out that they are not average dogs). I wrote a history of the breed, as well as the legend of the founder of the Dog-Ninja units.
These are in parts of my work which I have not submitted here (Posting 150 MS Word pages on the Critique board probably won't win me any friends).

And I took the story away from the series almost completely, killing close to all of the main characters and changing the setting and undertones of the world before shaping the remaining cast to my liking and adding a fresh set of my original characters.

But thanks for the heads up mate. Good to know that people here will tell me if I'm doing something wrong :)

***

In any case, I just want to say that this piece... I never planned for it to get away on me like this.

I was lazing around the Internet one day (as one does) and I was directed to an extremely well written FanFic set in the same universe which I identified with (as dumb as it sounds, being that I'm talking about a FanFic for an Anime).
It was this work that I wrote the beginning of my story about, as a 'thank-you' to the writer and his community.

When it was posted I got a snowstorm of positive reviews. But more importantly, it was my first taste of real writing, as much as it can be considered to be real writing.
Before then my creative writing had not been particularly good, and the positive reviews and my own psyche got me thinking.

I thought of a way to have the story continue, and I took it.

And here I am with this massive project in front of me, using this as a training exercise for writing my own original novel.

I guess what my insomnia related rambling and ranting here is trying to convey is that I have improved much since my beginning. And much of the important stuff I learned was right here, from users reviewing my work.

For that, thanks everyone :)

And now I'm off to bed...

Cheers all, and if you have anything to add, I'm always up for criticism/abuse/rotten vegetable peltings ;)
 
Oh the nin-dogs are like shinobi+inu instead of like hito+inu.

I was wondering what the purpose of half human, half dog like dogs was in the first place.:eek:
 
Yeah, it is a Ninja with a special dog as a teammate. They function much like police dog units, except geared heavily for combat (mundane and Jutsu based) as well as being excellent trackers.

A little info on the dogs...

To enable the Nin-dog to perform Ninja techniques the shinobi channels his/her chakra into the animal as they perform the seals with their hands, as th dog has no chakra reserve of it's own.

While one or two dogs to a Ninja is the norm, some choose to field a veritable pack of slightly weaker Nin-dog, upwards of ten which utilize their superior numbers against enemies.

Nin-dogs are capable of communication with Dog-Nin, who can understand their growls and barks clearly. In addition the dogs can understand humans quite clearly, and can even have a high intelligence capable of understanding complex matters.

*****

Hope this helps :)
 
You have the workings of a very good writer overall. However, you just need to work a little bit on your tendency to create those "epic" run-ons. Some sentences are not too long, though. They just need some more commas to help with their flow.

Example:

"Despite the fresh air circulating through the tea house’s front room[,] the building gave off the musty smell of dust and decay."

In addition, some segments you use repetetive descriptive words very heavily. I always try to find synonyms or perhaps even metaphorical ways to describe something in order to avoid repetition.

Example:

"The old wooden floorboards were warped unevenly from periodic exposure to the elements through the broken front windows and in places were fractured or broken, shards of the shattered pane gathering in the breaks and recessions."

Added to that, this sentence could use an overall rewoking and perhaps could be broken into several smaller passages.

Just a few editting issues that can easily be taken care of with some careful proof-reading. Still, keep up the good work :D.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top