Spirit. Please critique. (Short story, some violent content)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Torthane

Resident schmuck.
Joined
Jun 1, 2007
Messages
14
I wrote this a while back and wanted to know what you guys think of it. Comments on style, flow, characters, and plot would be most welcome. Thanks all, and I hope you enjoy it.



Spirit


There it was again, a distant blast that rattled the brochure plastered windows of the little coffee shop.


Spirit switched off her newspaper and looked around the usually peaceful shop. The other customers were sitting at tables near the windows or were sprawled out on couches. Most of them were still sitting down but the apprehension flowing over their faces was almost comically evident. For ten or fifteen seconds nothing stirred in the shop.
Spirit leaned back in her chair and said quietly, “Samantha, wake up.”


What is it Spirit?” a calm female voice replied in her head; it was her Samantha device speaking. Spirit had only had Samantha for two months, but she already depended on her for schedule reminders, telecommunication, and weather and medical reports. But Samantha was more than a personal computer embedded in Spirit's head; she was a constant source of comfort, an ever listening ear happy to let Spirit pour out her troubles. It was something even her roommate and best friend, Jinny, couldn't handle.


Samantha, are there any government reports on the gun batteries?”


For the whole system, or just Seareach?” There was another earth shaking bang.


Spirit inadvertently started biting her fingernails. “Tell me about the batteries in Pillar, Seareach.”


The Pillar City weapon batteries are active. Are you all right? Your heart rate is up, but I'm not recording much muscle activity.”


I'm scared, Samantha. What if it's Nocs?” Spirit stared out of the window nearby.
Stay calm, remember your training, and don't worry. Everything will turn out just fine,” the calm voice soothed.


Spirit wasn't listening. Her eyes were fixed on the large rectangle of glass and the scene in the streets on the other side. A freezing shudder ran down her spine as she gazed at the people standing in the street. Their faces were turned to the sky and countless hands were stretched upwards to block the harsh blaze of sun mirrors. Hundreds of people, united in that strangest of salutes, squinted up at the heavens.


She stood up and walked over to the window and tried to look worried or unsettled. She stopped at the window and jumped back with an undignified squeak. There was a woman's face in the glass. She stared at Spirit with wide green eyes in an expression of great fear. Her young face was well sculpted from her sharp chin to her high cheek bones. The only features that detracted from her simple beauty were her slightly large nose and a curious little black blemish under her right eye that peeked out from behind a loose lock of black hair. With a sheepish little laugh Spirit realized that she was looking at her own reflection in the glass. The little spot on her cheek was a badge of pride, a billboard advertising that her skin was all natural and had never been touched by Gloride or any other beauty drug for that matter.


Spirit recalled why she had gone to the window in the first place and shifted her gaze upward.


No good.


She pressed her cheek against the window and looked further up, but still her vision was filled with the closely packed buildings lining the street outside. The concrete structures reached hundreds of feet into the air like the walls of a mighty gorge. The building shook violently as another cannon report reached her ears. This one was much closer.


She rushed for the exit and ran out into the broad street; the other customers of the coffee shop and even its employees ran out after her. She ran out into the middle of the intersection of WE-35 and NS-71 and tilted her head back. Like everyone around her she raised her hand to block the giant solar mirror that bounced sunlight down into the cement canyon where she stood. Through the grid of transport rails crisscrossing from building to building she could see the pale turquoise firmament swirling above her and the reason for the horrified skyward gaze that she now shared in.

****

That morning had started like most of Spirit's mornings did with the irritating whine of her alarm clock going off. She had tried having Samantha wake her, but the result had somehow been highly disconcerting. Spirit had finally given up the idea after Jinny's constant complaining that the first thing she always heard in the morning were Spirit's piercing shrieks rebounding off the walls of their apartment.


After the alarm's auditory assault was switched off by Spirit's blindly groping arm, she lay in bed for another fifteen minutes as she listened to Jinny singing in the shower to the newest Red Thimble chart topper or thrashing with the driving beats of a 3-2-1-Scream album. Then the music and the water stopped and Jinny went back to her room wrapped in towel, but still playing air-guitar. Spirit got out of bed with a groan and stumbled for the wash-and-waste-room, jokingly known as the double-double-U-room or even occasionally the quadruple-U-room.


Spirit stepped into the dripping shower chamber and switched the audio player over to Amanda Brissen as the steaming water flowed over what she considered her embarrassingly white skin. The naturally dark skinned Jinny even sometimes jokingly called her 'The Albino', but Spirit preferred to be pale skinned rather than pump tanning drugs into her system, and she didn't have the time to take frequent trips to the solar chambers where she could get real sunlight. Spirit let her muscles relax as Amanda's ethereal vocals soared through the steam-laden air.


By the time Spirit was finished with her shower and was fully dressed, Jinny was already munching an energy bar while she ran over the simulated beaches of the Saint Yarren coastline in the DRD, or digital reality dome. Spirit sat down for her breakfast as she watched the news projected on the kitchen wall-screen. She switched over to combat correspondence and got the latest information on the Nocuous War. She had friends serving in the navy and every time the ship losses came up she rapidly scanned over the screen dreading to find FAR-221, “The Harpy”, on the list of starships that had been destroyed.


Her friends' boat did not show up on the casualty report, and Spirit switched over to combat footage feeds with a sigh of relief. She selected 'Victories' from the drop down list and scrolled down to an entry she had viewed at least a dozen times. She usually couldn't stand to watch the combat feeds, but this particular recording seemed to hold her captive. It was like her addiction to caffeine. She believed she could turn away from it at a moment's notice but never actually did.


The recording rolled and she fast-forwarded through the brutal ship-to-ship fighting raging on the screen and resumed normal play of the video after the vicious gunfire stopped and the blood spattered rooms of the Nocuous Frigate were quiet. The feed was coming from the helmet-cam of a young NCI who narrated the footage.
NCI Perinson, CAS-753. I've got a Nocker still kicking over here.” His voice was unsteady with adrenalin as he slowly walked towards a wounded Noc soldier. His combat boots crunched down on spent shells littering the metal floor with each step towards the convulsing Nocuos curled up on the ground ahead of him.


The naval infantryman stopped a little ways away and continued his narrative, “Looks like she got nailed two or three times in the gut. As you can see, real mess. Dusters make way bigger holes than repeaters.” Even though all Nocuos were clad entirely in jet black armor, the NCI could tell that this one was female from the pitiful moans coming from her streamlined helmet's mouthpiece. Something about the Noc armor always made Spirit involuntarily shudder, almost as if it were designed to look like death. The sleek lines on the arm plates, the obsidian quality of the whole suit, and above all else the emotionless face of the helmet with its chilling stare, the notorious devil's fencing mask.


The NCI continued his shaken commentary as Spirit watched the screen intently, “I'm going to take her helmet off.” He stepped closer with a fluidity of movement that was all but a trademark of naval personnel and starfarers in general.


He knelt down next to the Nocuos and fumbled around with her helmet muttering to himself, “Never seen one of you before....Come on. How do you get this thing off?”
There was a click and a hiss and the NCI detached the helmet. His voice was a breath starved whisper as he looked down, “Oh, God. Dear, dear, God.” Staring up at him was a human woman. She had no hair and no pigment in her face either. Her skin was white, her lips were white, but her eyes, oh mercy her eyes, they were black. Solid black like an animal's. Around the woman's neck was a tight metal band, laced with wires that borrowed into her skin like electronic insects. The cruel necklaces had come to be called 'harvest bands' and were confirmed to be a mind control device of sorts.


Spirit stopped the recording and swallowed. They would never harvest her; she would kill herself first if it came to that.

****

Up in the sky Spirit could see bright flashes of light. Nocuos landers tore through the atmosphere, their black hulls glowing red hot from the heat of reentry. As she stared up she heard herself repeating over and over again, “No, no, no, no.”


Then there was a terrible roar and the ground seemed to move out from under Spirit's feet. Her vision was blurred as she picked herself up off the pavement, and warm blood was trickling out of her ears. A gun battery had gone off not two blocks away, and she couldn't hear anything but Samantha's perpetually calm voice in her head.


Spirit, you need to see a regenerative physician. Your ears are badly damaged.”


Spirit didn't respond, but rather turned her eyes back upward again. A brief moment passed and then high up in the sky thousands of explosions went off simultaneously, lighting up the sky in a lethal display of fireworks that tore many of the rapidly descending landers to shreds in showers of burning metal.


The battery had not stopped all of the Nocuos ships, though, and with each passing second the black craft plummeted closer and closer to the city below. Spirit's mind screamed for her to run as Samantha reminded her to see a doctor once again. But it was too late to escape. The landers crashed through the transport rails and came to rest on the road below with bone shaking impact and clouds of dust and debris. When the clouds cleared they sat there like giant mechanical centipedes, their many engines still vomiting flames into the street.


Now Spirit ran, faster than she ever thought she could move, sprinting towards the coffee shop. She flew through the door and slammed against the shop counter to stop herself, not even noticing the bruise on her hip the sudden deceleration had given her. She scrambled over the counter and sat there panting uncontrollably, but hidden from the street.


When her labored breathing finally slowed she could dimly hear muffled explosions from outside and the dull thud of gunfire in her broken ears. She cautiously peered over the counter top, but couldn't see what was happening outside the shop. Though her emergency training and common sense protested, she crept towards the window and looked out at the horror outside.


Nocuos soldiers were running everywhere shooting at the flying security bots that served as the humans' first responders to Nocuos attacks. Despite it all she laughed to herself. She could see civilians scurrying about, shedding any black clothing they were wearing. The security bots tracked friend from foe by the fact that all Nocuos armor was pitch black. Naturally, the human government had discouraged black clothing for safety reasons, but some of the younger people tried to show they were rebellious souls by wearing that very color.


Spirit was wondering if the bots would shoot at her because of her black hair when there was a blinding flash, a staggering impact to her stomach, and she was surprised to see the window in front of her shattered and sprayed with crimson. And then she felt a horrible ripping feeling, as if someone were slowly tearing her stomach open with both hands.


She stumbled back to the counter and clutched at the bleeding hole. She closed her eyes tight and when she opened them again she was on her knees and a Nocuos was staring down at her with his devil's fencing mask. He held a steaming Duster rifle in his right hand and a harvest band was gripped tightly in his left. As Spirit's eyelids closed she could see her face, white and pale with those black eyes staring blindly ahead.


The Nocuos clamped the band around her neck and Spirit left the human race.
 
Lol! A black-haired bimbo! :D I'm joking, sorry. But she fails to recognise her own reflection -- perhaps she's dyed her hair! The moral of this tale: Never, ever cheat by describing your characters' features when looking into a mirror; a little ingenuity and you could show us what she looks like without resorting to that old method.

Anyway, aside from the overuse of adjectives, this piece has some good ideas. I like the voice she listens to in her ear -- it's like hearing voices but not being mad--

What's that you say? Oh, it wasn't you. Must have been those invisible muses... :D Well, my muses -- or the voices in my head -- are telling me you've also, in some places, done some telling instead of showing (in an expression of great fear). And you haven't inserted commas where they need to be; e.g., into some parenthetical expressions (the other customers of the coffee shop and even its employees ran out after her), a few missing hyphens (dark skinned Jinny), and you have a couple of repeats of "ran" in quick succession too. Still, I'll ignore the voices and say this extract is interesting. Hmm... pacing seemed a little too fast for my taste, however, and her death at the end was rather immediate; I got no sense of what her murder achieved. What was the overall theme? Moral? Premise? Without those a tale lacks purpose, seemingly just a random scene from a random person...

borrowed into her skin
I presume you mean burrowed.

In my opinion, the blast damaging her ears was well done. I liked the blood and the hearing loss you portrayed. Perhaps just a little more emotion in the scene would help. How does the loss make her feel? How does she show she's frightened? etc.

Well, that's my crit. Perhaps others will answer the rest of your questions. (I'm just waiting for everybody to contradict me. ;) )
 

There it was again, a distant blast that rattled the brochure plastered windows of the little coffee shop.

Spirit switched off her newspaper and looked around the usually peaceful shop. The other customers were sitting at tables near the windows or were sprawled out on couches. Most of them were still sitting down but the apprehension flowing over their faces was almost comically evident.
Personally I'd like to see more dramatic, personal impact here. It's your opening hook. Given what I know from later in your story it doesn't seem reasonable that there isn't a more paniced reaction in the shop to the blasts. This is not normal experience don't make everyone sit around doing the same thing. People react differently, I don't buy they all had the same expression. I'd like you to make me feel or hear the sounds of the blast. Personally rattling brochure covered windows sounds anticlimatic. I love the idea of this opening scene but I want to experience it with a little more realism.

For ten or fifteen seconds nothing stirred in the shop.
Spirit leaned back in her chair and said quietly, “Samantha, wake up.”

Personal computer implanted in head great but don't you think its a little ironic she has to speak aloud to it, let alone telling it to wake up?

Also later you show that she is feeling some anxiety, I'd like that to be reflected here.



What is it Spirit?” a calm female voice replied in her head; it was her Samantha device speaking. Spirit had only had Samantha for two months, but she already depended on her for schedule reminders, telecommunication, and weather and medical reports. But Samantha was more than a personal computer embedded in Spirit's head; she was a constant source of comfort, an ever listening ear happy to let Spirit pour out her troubles. It was something even her roommate and best friend, Jinny, couldn't handle.

Readers are fairly smart and we're used to the unusual in Science fiction and fantasy I don't think you need to give us so much description of exactly what Samantha is at least not in this manner, nor refer to it personally by Samantha in the prior paragraph then call it a samantha device now. Let us know by later by example everything Samanthat can do or what she means to Spirit, or maybe not quite as much detail here. Personally I'd do it something like this:

Spirit heard the gentle chime of Samantha coming online in her head.
"Access reports on government gun batteries"

Samantha, are there any government reports on the gun batteries?”
For the whole system, or just Seareach?” There was another earth shaking bang.

I think it ironic that your name of town is Seareach it reminds me of Search. For a brief moment I thought it an atrocious misspelling and that you were asking the computer just to do a local search. It gave me a brief mental jar which slowed down the text for me.
Earth shaking bang I think you could show something falling or some type of action here. This sounds very cliche.

Spirit inadvertently started biting her fingernails. “Tell me about the batteries in Pillar, Seareach.”
The Pillar City weapon batteries are active. Are you all right? Your heart rate is up, but I'm not recording much muscle activity.”

I like what you want to do as actions here and showing us the computer is somehow wired into her that it moniters her heart and muscle activity. It is throwing me off a little that the computer is so personal with her, but I love the concept of that it is programmed to be more of a friend internal companion as well as useful purposes. I'd almost like to have you skip giving us the description of Spirit biting her nails and work it into Samantha's reply, if your going to make it a computer with a heart or personality enough to care then give it some personality. I think you are wanting to show here that Samantha can moniter physical distress but she doesn't understand it when it is emotions causing it and no direct physical activity.


I'm scared, Samantha. What if it's Nocs?” Spirit stared out of the window nearby.
Stay calm, remember your training, and don't worry. Everything will turn out just fine,” the calm voice soothed.

I'm starting to dislike whoever programmed your computer. I hate this response to I'm scared, it's such a cliche politically correct response. Of course I'm the type of person though if someone asks How are you? I don't just give back a standard response of Fine, great thanks for asking.

Spirit wasn't listening. Her eyes were fixed on the large rectangle of glass and the scene in the streets on the other side. A freezing shudder ran down her spine as she gazed at the people standing in the street. Their faces were turned to the sky and countless hands were stretched upwards to block the harsh blaze of sun mirrors. Hundreds of people, united in that strangest of salutes, squinted up at the heavens.

Second time you mentioned the window and her staring outside. Again I question that they all have the same response are they a society of clones. Do they all act with one mind except your main character? Because right now that is what you are showing me. Are they under some kind of alien control by the light? I don't think this scene as you paint it makes alot of sense or maybe we need to see later why there is this common reaction. It is a nice description and it paints a bizarre and compelling picture yet do you have a realistic reason for it. I got the impression you didn't that you were just painting in that description because it sounded nice and while it does is it really how your society would react given the circumstances.


She stood up and walked over to the window and tried to look worried or unsettled. She stopped at the window and jumped back with an undignified squeak. There was a woman's face in the glass. She stared at Spirit with wide green eyes in an expression of great fear. Her young face was well sculpted from her sharp chin to her high cheek bones. The only features that detracted from her simple beauty were her slightly large nose and a curious little black blemish under her right eye that peeked out from behind a loose lock of black hair. With a sheepish little laugh Spirit realized that she was looking at her own reflection in the glass. The little spot on her cheek was a badge of pride, a billboard advertising that her skin was all natural and had never been touched by Gloride or any other beauty drug for that matter.

Have to agree with Leisha's comments on this one about describing character.
I'll add that saying "she tried to look worried or unsettled" doesn't make much sense. Is she putting on a show for someone's benefit? Or did you mean to do direct action here? You've already established that she is worried earlier.

Spirit recalled why she had gone to the window in the first place and shifted her gaze upward.


No good.
What isnt good?


She pressed her cheek against the window and looked further up, but still her vision was filled with the closely packed buildings lining the street outside. The concrete structures reached hundreds of feet into the air like the walls of a mighty gorge. The building shook violently as another cannon report reached her ears. This one was much closer.

It seems like she has lived in the city a long time and if she is trained why isn't she doing something constructive here? She must know if she looks out a window she can't see the sky so why would she try to look out the window instead of joining people in the street right away if you really need her to look up. I think you havent thought out this section clearly because it is quite obvious its an attack of some kind. If they are at war or know about a threat they should have some kind of action plan. Or if threat was totally unknown there should be some kind of chaos.
She rushed for the exit and ran out into the broad street; the other customers of the coffee shop and even its employees ran out after her. She ran out into the middle of the intersection of WE-35 and NS-71 and tilted her head back. Like everyone around her she raised her hand to block the giant solar mirror that bounced sunlight down into the cement canyon where she stood. Through the grid of transport rails crisscrossing from building to building she could see the pale turquoise firmament swirling above her and the reason for the horrified skyward gaze that she now shared in.

I like the description here again but I dislike having a main character that is a sheep. Sorry but she's simply going along with the crowd and doing exactly the same thing everyone else is doing with no compelling reason to do so. If what is in the air is so horrifying why is everyone dumbstruck give me a reason here.
That morning had started like most of Spirit's mornings did with the irritating whine of her alarm clock going off. She had tried having Samantha wake her, but the result had somehow been highly disconcerting. Spirit had finally given up the idea after Jinny's constant complaining that the first thing she always heard in the morning were Spirit's piercing shrieks rebounding off the walls of their apartment


I don't like you doing the flashback here. I'd rather you started with this series of events and let the story flow. I think you could do a very dramatic entrance by just showing the television series of the Noc attacks. Is this paragraph relevant to the plot at all?



After the alarm's auditory assault was switched off by Spirit's blindly groping arm, she lay in bed for another fifteen minutes as she listened to Jinny singing in the shower to the newest Red Thimble chart topper or thrashing with the driving beats of a 3-2-1-Scream album. Then the music and the water stopped and Jinny went back to her room wrapped in towel, but still playing air-guitar. Spirit got out of bed with a groan and stumbled for the wash-and-waste-room, jokingly known as the double-double-U-room or even occasionally the quadruple-U-room.
Spirit stepped into the dripping shower chamber and switched the audio player over to Amanda Brissen as the steaming water flowed over what she considered her embarrassingly white skin. The naturally dark skinned Jinny even sometimes jokingly called her 'The Albino', but Spirit preferred to be pale skinned rather than pump tanning drugs into her system, and she didn't have the time to take frequent trips to the solar chambers where she could get real sunlight. Spirit let her muscles relax as Amanda's ethereal vocals soared through the steam-laden air.

By the time Spirit was finished with her shower and was fully dressed, Jinny was already munching an energy bar while she ran over the simulated beaches of the Saint Yarren coastline in the DRD, or digital reality dome.


I don't really see how this segment is moving plot forward
Spirit sat down for her breakfast as she watched the news projected on the kitchen wall-screen. She switched over to combat correspondence and got the latest information on the Nocuous War. She had friends serving in the navy and every time the ship losses came up she rapidly scanned over the screen dreading to find FAR-221, “The Harpy”, on the list of starships that had been destroyed.
Her friends' boat did not show up on the casualty report, and Spirit switched over to combat footage feeds with a sigh of relief. She selected 'Victories' from the drop down list and scrolled down to an entry she had viewed at least a dozen times. She usually couldn't stand to watch the combat feeds, but this particular recording seemed to hold her captive. It was like her addiction to caffeine. She believed she could turn away from it at a moment's notice but never actually did.


The recording rolled and she fast-forwarded through the brutal ship-to-ship fighting raging on the screen and resumed normal play of the video after the vicious gunfire stopped and the blood spattered rooms of the Nocuous Frigate were quiet. The feed was coming from the helmet-cam of a young NCI who narrated the footage.
NCI Perinson, CAS-753. I've got a Nocker still kicking over here.” His voice was unsteady with adrenalin as he slowly walked towards a wounded Noc soldier. His combat boots crunched down on spent shells littering the metal floor with each step towards the convulsing Nocuos curled up on the ground ahead of him.


The naval infantryman stopped a little ways away and continued his narrative, “Looks like she got nailed two or three times in the gut. As you can see, real mess. Dusters make way bigger holes than repeaters.” Even though all Nocuos were clad entirely in jet black armor, the NCI could tell that this one was female from the pitiful moans coming from her streamlined helmet's mouthpiece. Something about the Noc armor always made Spirit involuntarily shudder, almost as if it were designed to look like death. The sleek lines on the arm plates, the obsidian quality of the whole suit, and above all else the emotionless face of the helmet with its chilling stare, the notorious devil's fencing mask.


The NCI continued his shaken commentary as Spirit watched the screen intently, “I'm going to take her helmet off.” He stepped closer with a fluidity of movement that was all but a trademark of naval personnel and starfarers in general.


He knelt down next to the Nocuos and fumbled around with her helmet muttering to himself, “Never seen one of you before....Come on. How do you get this thing off?”
There was a click and a hiss and the NCI detached the helmet. His voice was a breath starved whisper as he looked down, “Oh, God. Dear, dear, God.” Staring up at him was a human woman. She had no hair and no pigment in her face either. Her skin was white, her lips were white, but her eyes, oh mercy her eyes, they were black. Solid black like an animal's. Around the woman's neck was a tight metal band, laced with wires that borrowed into her skin like electronic insects. The cruel necklaces had come to be called 'harvest bands' and were confirmed to be a mind control device of sorts.


Spirit stopped the recording and swallowed. They would never harvest her; she would kill herself first if it came to that.

Personally really slow section for me. Some very good ideas but the flow is slow for me. Why would she flip threw the combat feeds if she disliked them. I'd personally tighten up this section you have alot of information but is it all really necessary?

****
The flow ebbs between fast and slow and I think you'd be better served as I stated earlier getting rid of the flashback and doing it all chronological. I'd love to see Samantha have some type of personality and be ironic or something. I'd like to see your character and the populace actions make some kind of sense and be realistic and if it isnt a normal reaction I'd like to at least be given a hint of why not.

Overall good description but I think you are concentrating more on the visual picture then how it is relevant to your plotline.
 
Well thank you both for your very helpful critiques! I wrote this about four months ago for a school project and I have changed some things since then when it comes to writing style. You were both very helpful and I am greateful that you would take some time to read through this and give me some pointers. I am working on another short story and I will try to incorparate your suggestions into it. Thanks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top