3.05: Progeny

Highlander II

There can be only one!!
Jun 6, 2001

Dr. Weir accompanies Sheppard's team on a mission to an advanced civilization with a past history with Atlantis. They uncover a connection to an earlier discovery in the city.


Non Bio
Staff member
Jan 5, 2001
Way on Down South, London Town
They meet a civilisation who clame to be Ancients - Ancients who don't want to ascend - or maybe they can't. They had a falling out long ago with the other Ancients over how to deal with the Wraith. They have a plan to destroy the Wraith, but they aren't telling it. The team is suspicious; they don't seem like Ancients. Maybe they just found the city, in the same way thay they found Atlantis.

As they are about to leave they are captured. Seemingly, they escape to Atlantis and then tens of Wraith ships turn up. They know exactly how to disable and destroy the defences. Earth s dialled and as they are about to escape, Shepard wakes up. Something similiar to a Replicator is reading his mind. The others have had similar dreams.

These are not the same as the Milky Way Replicators. They result from the creation of nanobots by the Ancients to fight the Wraith. They have now evolved as far as the can, but want to emulate their creators and Ascend.

One of them helps the team to really escape. He thinks that the aggressiveness preprogrammed into them is what is stopping them Ascend. Rodney is able to reprogram his base code and they steal a jumper and leave. But the other replicators reach out to him and revert him back. When he attacks Weir the team eject him from the Jumper.

These were too much like the Milky Way Replicators. If it is some fundamental rule that artificial robotic life is always going to evolve into creatures like this then fair enough, but Rodney would need to provide me with some detailed evidence.

They now know the location of Atlantis and of Earth. One of them said "More Bad Guys", I can't remember who, but too right!


Certified Space Monkey
Jun 26, 2002
I was beginning to like this episode until they used the McKay get-out clause i.e. - any technological problem can be solved by McKay in 20 mins if he's under pressure, even if it is as complex as 're-coding the DNA double helix'.

The replicators did seem to be the introduction of an enemy greater than the Goa'uld - whoops! I mean Wraith!! This seem familiar to anyone else?
It does seem that they are starting to transfer stuff from the SG-1 side of things to Atlantis, almost pre-empting the cancellation of SG-1.

Also thought that they should have stolen a couple of puddle-jumpers to top up their stock, having lost one or two, but then it occured to me - wouldn't the jumpers be made of replicator blocks as well, or did they build everything out of raw materials, rather than replicator blocks like their counterparts in this galaxy?
Hopefully loose ends will be tied up later in the series.


Celestial Paradox
Jan 12, 2007
Umm... I did enjoy it, but I'm not sure why they have decided to bring back the Replicators. Surely they would have been better off creating a new enemy if they wanted someone other than the Wraith to cause Atlantis problems.

Some great scenes in it though, such as the flying city.