Is this a good description?

Kryshon

Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2004
Messages
5
Hello all, I've finally decided to stop leaving books half finished, so I've started a writing spree with a bookm of mine. So far, I've written all 19 pages in two days, but there are some things that I'm wondering. First off, I'll paste a description text here, because I'm not sure if I've done it right.

Just to let you know in advance, this particular scene is set around three thousand years in the future, and the original inhabitants of planet Mars, reptilians as I call them, cloaked their planet to keep others away, until they evaluated their system's companions and then revealed themselves. I realise that Mars isn't an imaginative planet, but I wanted this to be our future, and I had to find a planet near Earth for my favorite species.

So, here's my description. Mainly I want to know if it's too long or poorly structured. I make hundreds of typos, so I'm not looking for grammar or spelling, since I know I'll be having problems with those. This is not something short, but if you have the time, please read it and give your advice.

The Dragon Wing was one of hundreds, maybe even thousands, of spaceships entering and exiting and cruising Martian space. Even the huge, defensive blockade of a hundred Federation Battlecruisers and the two orbiting Behemoth Battlecruisers were completely insignificant compared to the rest of the traffic around the capital of the Federation.

There were large convoys bearing trademarks of big companies. There were private fighters, public cruise liners, and ships that race each other from one ship to another, weaving through narrow ship corridors like photons running through fiber optics. Small, frigate-type ships – most of them personally owned – flew mockingly around Battlecruisers like slow gnats around a giant’s flexed hand. Every here and there, reptilian patrol boats shot menacingly at unruly space yatchs, while huge cargo vessels exchanged private agruments over who would have priority accessing so-and-so entry lane.

In the midst of this chaos sat the Mars’ Birther, a disproportionally huge space station, hundreds of kilometers long, that was in fact the famed martian shipyards. This huge mechanical monster churned out Battlecruisers, gunships, frigates, fighters, microdestroyers, droid vessels, reconnaissance ships and a whole spectrum of private vessels. The station was fiercly guarded by a locust swarm of federal microdestroyers; these were fighter-sized craft that packed the armament of a destroyer, plus a little more.

The worst part of all was that the ships and stations were completely disorganized and without any particular priorities. Reptilian space traffic officers, Othrum knew, had a blast watching the myriade of ships fend for themselves. All they did was randomly ask questions, send patrol craft after any ship that got too impatient at the terrible traffic, start casual conversations with those who happened to be reptilians, and yell at any ship trying to land anywhere other then a spaceport.

Ithruk set a course for one of the entry lanes to the city of Khsa. That particular city was less infamous then others like Ipeatind, Dyssal or Millyanium, but it was still safe, and a haven for the rich and the nature-lovers – it being conveniently situated on the border that separated the expansive martian red desert from the almost equally expansive martian rainforest.

As the Dragon Wing approached Mars, the planet finally became visible amidts all the chaos. It gleamed like a red, green and blue jewel in a sea of black space and metal hulls. Almost 95% of the terrestrial surface remained a pristine, untouched wilderness. This wilderness was so strongly protected by both the martian governement and the reptilian people that those who would have wanted to defile it in any way would have considered such an act suicidal.

The reptilian homeworld was truly a world of scales. Almost all of the native cratures belonged to either the reptile or the insect families, regardless of the fact that many of them had wings and behaved much like giant birds. Yet another trait of reptilian life; almost everything was big, surprisingly big for such a small planet. Reptilians were large for sentinents, and there were a collection of meter-long beetles, dragons, giant flying wyrms, whale-sized crustaceans that swam like sharks and lizards that preyed upon those meter-long beetles. This size can be partially explained by the fact that everything on Mars grows bigger with age, and that everything a thing from Mars eats goes to making it bigger and better; nothing is wasted. Absolutely nothing.

And the plants were also incredible. Most of them were biologically made to last for as long as there was enough fertilizer, water and sun to keep them alive; this has resulted in towering trees, many hundreds of meters tall, that were thicker then spaceships and older then most species of animal. The "rainforests" of Mars were home to a stunning variety of flying insects and agile reptiles that made their homes in the middle to top levels of the canopy alone. Most of the forest, however, was a sort of canopy forest; there were almost no branches for the first ten or twenty meters, but after that, the branches became imperceptibly more commone for hundreds upon hundreds of meters into the air, until ther covered so much of the sky that one could not see any light.

The oddest part about that, however, was that there was still a good deal of light at the bottom of the forest. This was due to something quite peculiar; martian plants had evolved to had the underside of their leave be reflective, like mirrors, to shine light back down to lower leaves and branches. Even with all the branches below them, some light managed to get down to the surface, and give the impression that, at ground level, the forest was constantly dusk.
 
Here's my deconstruction of your description. I've left out grammatical concerns, as per your request. I hope this helps!

The Dragon Wing was one of hundreds, maybe even thousands, of spaceships entering and exiting and cruising Martian space.

The word "cruising" would work fine on its own here.
" . . . maybe even thousands, of spaceships cruising Martian space." Also, you may want to think of a more interesting term than "spaceships." "Ships" maybe.

There were large convoys bearing trademarks of big companies. There were private fighters, public cruise liners, and ships that race each other from one ship to another, weaving through narrow ship corridors like photons running through fiber optics.

That's a lot of repetitions of the word "ship." Plus, are the racing ships moving at light speed? Cause that's what I think when you compare them to photons.

Small, frigate-type ships – most of them personally owned – flew mockingly around Battlecruisers like slow gnats around a giant’s flexed hand. Every here and there, reptilian patrol boats shot menacingly at unruly space yatchs, while huge cargo vessels exchanged private agruments over who would have priority accessing so-and-so entry lane.
There's something very relaxed about this description, though I get the implication that there's action going on here.
Try: "Small private skiffs glided mockingly around Battlecruisers - slow gnats around giants' hands. The captains of huge cargo vessels exchanged arguments over priority access to entry lanes. And, occasionally, a reptilian patrol boat opened fire on an unruly space yacht."

In the midst of this chaos sat the Mars’ Birther, a disproportionally huge space station, hundreds of kilometers long, that was in fact the famed martian shipyards.
"Disproportionate" implies "huge." It's huge because it's out of proportion. Better: "disproportionately large."

This huge mechanical monster churned out Battlecruisers, gunships, frigates, fighters, microdestroyers, droid vessels, reconnaissance ships and a whole spectrum of private vessels.
No need for another adjective here. Try: "This mechanical monster . . ."

All they did was randomly ask questions, send patrol craft after any ship that got too impatient at the terrible traffic, start casual conversations with those who happened to be reptilians, and yell at any ship trying to land anywhere other then a spaceport.
This is a bit clumsy. Try: "Amid consistently confused radio chatter, patrol craft hounded impatient pilots and any ship trying to dock anywhere besides a spaceport."

As the Dragon Wing approached Mars, the planet finally became visible amidts all the chaos.
This description makes it sounds as if all the space traffic is obscuring the planet Mars. Try: "As the Dragon Wing came through the chaos, Mars' surface features became visible."

This size can be partially explained by the fact that everything on Mars grows bigger with age, and that everything a thing from Mars eats goes to making it bigger and better; nothing is wasted. Absolutely nothing.
Try: "Everything the Martians consume goes to making them bigger and better; absolutley nothing is wasted."
Also, think about the tense. This sentence is in present tense -"Everything on Mars grows"- while the previous one is in past tense -"Reptilians were large."

Most of them were biologically made to last for as long as there was enough fertilizer, water and sun to keep them alive;
Here, you are effectively saying that the Martian plants were engineered to live until they died. It's a little bit redundant. Try: "Most of them were engineered to live forever on endless supplies of water and fertilizer . . ."

The oddest part about that, however, was that there was still a good deal of light at the bottom of the forest. This was due to something quite peculiar; martian plants had evolved to had the underside of their leave be reflective, like mirrors, to shine light back down to lower leaves and branches. Even with all the branches below them, some light managed to get down to the surface, and give the impression that, at ground level, the forest was constantly dusk.
Try: "Yet, there was still a good deal of light on the forest floor. This was due to the fact that the Martian plants had evolved leaves with reflective undersides; some light, bounced from these mirror-leaves, got throrough the canopy and give the impression that, at ground level, the forest was in a constant dusk."

Final thought:
You have a vision for this story and show a lot of potential. I think you will pleased with the way, as you write more, your writing will mature. You already have something many writers covet: a clear window. Through it, and you see the setting, you see the people in your story.
I'd like to see more from you!
 
Kryshon said:
The Dragon Wing was one of hundreds, maybe even thousands, of spaceships entering and exiting and cruising Martian space.
'Entering and exiting and cruising...', is akward, I think perhaps:

"The Dragon Wing was one of hundreds, maybe even thousands, of spaceships entering, exiting and cruising Martian space."
 
I had a quick read of the opening paragraph - and it does read very...distant. There's no factor to engage and draw the reader in - no experience of series of actions to draw the reader into any kind of emotional state. That is something that, in my opinion, can be a big mistake in writing.

Someone once made a point of drumming into my head that writing was not about writing stories, or images, or beautiful scences/characters/dialogie, etc - it's all about the internal character experience. Without that aspect, it's very hard to engage the reader into caring what they are reading about.

My personal recommendation would be to try and rewrite the above from a stronger character viewpoint - how do they feel about Martian Space? How are they expierencing it? Why is this set of actions so important and read-worthy - ie, where is it all going?

Simply a suggestion. :)
 

Similar threads


Back
Top