Elf in a Bear Trap (1005 words)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stable

Watching you from upside down
Joined
Oct 7, 2016
Messages
413
Here's the opening to a short story I've written recently. I wanted to do something in the D&D/Tolkien style of faux-medieval, elves and magical creatures etc. because I don't normally write that style. The idea was to write a non-epic short story in that kind of world. It goes on twice as long again, but frankly I hate the ending I have at the moment and need to find a new one. I'd love any feedback you guys have.


Rafe knew he was in trouble when he spotted a unicorn prancing nervously beside his bear trap. Its coat was white like a fresh cloud, its hooves burnished silver and it would spit him on that spiralled horn as soon as look at him. The damn elves trained them that way, and you wouldn’t find a unicorn without a pointy eared busynose close behind. The pit trap was clearly sprung and ruined, but he doubted a unicorn would be hanging around a caught bear. A nasty possibility started to unfold in his mind.

He took a moment to find a nice thick tree to stand beside in case the animal charged and cleared his throat. The unicorn’s head shot up, but it didn’t leave the side of the pit.

“Anyone in the hole?” He called. There was a slight pause before an impossibly sweet voice answered.

“Oh thank goodness! Someone’s here.” Great. He’d caught an elf. The day was going downhill.

“What did you jump into my bear trap for?” He yelled back. It was ruined now, and he’d most likely have to dig another pit if he wanted to catch the animal that had been raiding his stores. Rafe wasn’t as young as he used to be and his back was still twinging from this dig.

“This is yours?” The sweet voice was angry now. “You murderous…” A ball of unpleasant-looking purple energy lofted rapidly out of the pit before turning on a right angle and shooting straight at him. The tarnished old amulet he wore warmed against his chest as it shunted the spell off to his left, where it splashed against the tree. It left a patch of mouldering, rotted bark.

“Well, I guess you can pull yourself out then you gods-damned hypocrite!” Rafe turned and strode off back to his cottage.

His self-righteous anger cooled off a little as he reflected on who had dug the hole the elf was stuck in, but it wasn’t until that evening when the wind picked up and the heavy clouds started rolling in that he decided to go back. He didn’t like to think about the survival prospects of anyone stuck in a hole on a cold, stormy night. Unfortunately the unicorn, and by extension the elf, was still there.

“Storm’s coming, elf. You want out or are you going to curse at me again?” Rafe said.

“Just go away. My people will come and find me soon enough.” The elf sounded tired and resigned. As if called by name, the first few heavy drops started thudding into the leaves and dirt around them.

“If I leave you here now you’ll be up to your armpits in cold mud before nightfall. Get your animal out of the way, I’ve got a rope and I’m going to pull you out.” Rafe started making his way towards the trap, carefully keeping it between him and the unicorn. The voice called out some sing-song words in elvish, and although it looked at him suspiciously the unicorn kept to its side of the pit.

“I don’t know how much I can help you. I believe my leg is broken.” The elf said as Raph lowered the rope into the hole.

“Just tie the rope under your shoulders.” He replied. “I’ll do the rest.”

The rain was coming down in earnest by the time the elf signalled it was ready. Before he had gone more than a few steps Rafe slipped in the mud, landing on his face, and the elf screamed from the pit as it was no doubt dropped back onto a broken leg. When he climbed back to his feet he found the wet, glistening point of the unicorn’s horn in front of his chest.

“Don’t threaten me you damn beast! Try being useful instead.” Amazingly the animal dropped its head, looped the rope around its horn and turned resolutely away from the hole. Rafe grabbed the rope again and together they hauled a whimpering, soaked figure out of the bear trap. He hadn’t seen an elf in years, but they were normally aloof, ethereal and elegant. Collapsed into a soaking muddy heap the elf before him seemed tiny and pitiable. The broken bones looked particularly out of place in the elf’s narrow leg, more worryingly the whimpering had stopped.

The unicorn had dumped the rope and now stood over the elf, nuzzling its arm gently. Rafe gently picked up the limp figure – he started to assume the elf was male now he looked closer, but it was very hard to tell - and draped him over the unicorn’s back. The unicorn kept a suspicious eye on Rafe, but it allowed all of this without complaint.

“There, he’s out. You can come to my home and get dry or you can trot off your own way.” He said, feeling silly for talking to an animal. Rafe didn’t know whether to be pleased or annoyed when it started to follow.

Rafe’s home was a single-roomed woodsman’s cottage with a thatched roof. The unicorn, being shorter and more slender than a horse, was able to fit through the door despite the passenger draped over its back. It looked around at the messed blankets and furs, piled up dirty dishes and other signs of the bachelor life and snorted horsily.

“And I’m sure you clean your own stall out by yourself.” He muttered, feeling judged. The unicorn didn’t respond.

Rafe stoked the fire up and placed the elf by it in the only comfy chair to dry off. Then he used the mercy of unconsciousness to set the elf’s leg and splinted it as best he could, with the unicorn peering critically over his shoulder the whole time. He described what he was doing to the watching unicorn, which he decided to call Blossom, although it probably had some ridiculous name in Elvish.

Transferring the elf to his bed, Rafe gave Blossom an apple, settled down in the chair and fell asleep watching the unicorn nibble around the core.
 
I didn't get a Tolkienesque or faux-mediaeval feel from it, partly because the voice is modern and Rafe is a real name, and partly because unicorns suggest, to me at least, a different stripe of fantasy. Could it work as a real-world bear trapper in the woods encountering these fantastical creatures?

There are typos but it's certainly engaging in general, you avoid infodumps and over-describing, sentence and paragraph structure seems dead-on. The style reminds me of Terry Bisson or Larry Niven.
 
Very nice. 'in case the animal charged and cleared his throat' just needs a comma to avoid being 'a man with a moustache named Pete.'
 
I didn't get a Tolkienesque or faux-mediaeval feel from it, partly because the voice is modern and...
Fair point! If it was a real-world trapper it would be hard to keep him as grumpy, though I'm sure it could be done.

Thanks @Wruter and @J Riff !
 
And this is why Gygaxian and Tolkienesque should be two different things :p Fits quite nicely into the former, nothing like the latter.

I like it though.

There's an obvious question of why Pointy McEars can't just magic his way out of trouble - I presume you answer that later in the story.

"Transferring the elf to his bed, Rafe gave Blossom an apple, settled down in the chair and fell asleep watching the unicorn nibble around the core." - This sentence feels a bit clumsy - I doubt Rafe did all three of those things at once, but it reads that way.
 
Kinda depends on what age your intended audience is. If MG it could work, but with around half removed. by that i mean there's a heck of a lot of words, where less would not only do, but would be more effective. definitely some likable moments, but would prefer to see a edited reduced version before I'd be able to offer detailed commentary.
 
Kinda depends on what age your intended audience is. If MG it could work, but with around half removed. by that i mean there's a heck of a lot of words, where less would not only do, but would be more effective. definitely some likable moments, but would prefer to see a edited reduced version before I'd be able to offer detailed commentary.
I was aiming more at an adult, or at most YA audience who had read enough fantasy to know the tropes. Do you feel I was writing in a way aimed at a less mature audience? In what way?
I'm sure I could cut words and it would be better off. I tried the last 300 word story challenge and managed to cut from 450 to 300 words while barely losing any information, so that was eye opening.

@The Big Peat
That is an obvious question in hindsight. In my head the magic can't do that, but I didn't make that specifically clear, so good pickup.

Thanks for the feedback both!
 
I was aiming more at an adult, or at most YA audience who had read enough fantasy to know the tropes. Do you feel I was writing in a way aimed at a less mature audience? In what way?
I'm sure I could cut words and it would be better off. I tried the last 300 word story challenge and managed to cut from 450 to 300 words while barely losing any information, so that was eye opening.

@The Big Peat
That is an obvious question in hindsight. In my head the magic can't do that, but I didn't make that specifically clear, so good pickup.

Thanks for the feedback both!
Well I suppose the subject matter, the tone and the interactions between the characters. I think it could work well for that age range, a sort of fun tongue in cheek approach to the classical tropes. I'd like to do a more detailed crit, in my particular style, which tends to be the (lazy/ time poor) re-write rather than the detailed analysis. Hmmm, might just have a spare 20 mins...
 
Here's the opening to a short story I've written recently. I wanted to do something in the D&D/Tolkien style of faux-medieval, elves and magical creatures etc. because I don't normally write that style. The idea was to write a non-epic short story in that kind of world. It goes on twice as long again, but frankly I hate the ending I have at the moment and need to find a new one. I'd love any feedback you guys have.


Rafe knew he was in trouble when he spotted a unicorn prancing nervously beside his (the, his is too confusing) bear trap. Its coat was white like a fresh cloud, its hooves burnished silver and it would spit him (confusing, reads like would spit on him) on that spiralled horn as soon as look at him. The damn elves trained them that way, and you wouldn’t find a unicorn [without a pointy eared busynose close behind] confusing, remove). The pit trap was clearly sprung and ruined, but he doubted a unicorn would be hanging around a caught bear. A nasty possibility started to unfold in his mind. I'd suggest removing all of this.

He (Rafe took) took a moment to find a nice thick tree to stand beside in case the animal charged and cleared his throat. The unicorn’s head shot up, but it didn’t leave the side of the pit.

“Anyone in the hole?” He called (called out). There was a slight pause before an impossibly sweet voice answered.

“Oh thank goodness! Someone’s here.”

(break) Great. He’d caught an elf. The day was going downhill. “What did you jump into my bear trap for?” He yelled back. It was ruined now, and he’d most likely have to dig another pit if he wanted to catch the animal that had been raiding his stores. Rafe wasn’t as young as he used to be and his back was still twinging from this dig. (move to later or delete)

“This is yours?” The sweet voice was angry now. “You murderous…” (Ok, but why murderous? Murderous is a pretty big concept to throw around so early) [A ball of unpleasant-looking purple energy lofted rapidly out of the pit before turning on a right angle and shooting straight at him. The tarnished old amulet he wore warmed against his chest as it shunted the spell off to his left, where it splashed against the tree. It left a patch of mouldering, rotted bark. (This is nice)]

“Well, I guess you can pull yourself out then you gods-damned hypocrite!” (Why hypocrite? You're assuming that we the reader, understand complex societal norms for these folk, whom we've just met) Rafe turned and strode off back to his cottage.

His self-righteous anger cooled off a little as he reflected on who had dug the hole the elf was stuck in, but
It wasn’t until that evening when the wind picked up and the heavy clouds started rolling, and his anger had cooled off a little, that he decided to go back. He didn’t like to think about the survival prospects of anyone stuck in a hole on a cold, stormy night. Unfortunately the unicorn, and by extension the elf, was still there.

“Storm’s coming, elf. You want out or are you going to curse at me again?” Rafe said.

“Just go away. My people will come and find me soon enough.” The elf sounded tired and resigned. As if called by name, the first few heavy drops of rain thudded onto the leaves around them.

“If I leave you here now you’ll be up to your armpits in cold mud before nightfall. Get your animal (unicorn) out of the way, I’ve got a rope and I’m going to pull you out.” {Rafe started making his way towards the trap, carefully keeping it between him and the unicorn. The voice called out some sing-song words in elvish, and although it looked at him suspiciously the unicorn kept to its side of the pit.] THis is confusing, you need to simplify)

“I don’t know how much I can help you. I believe my leg is broken.” The elf said as Raph (Rafe) lowered the rope into the hole.

“Just tie the rope under your shoulders,” Rafe said. “I’ll do the rest.”

The rain was coming down in earnest by the time the elf signalled it was ready. Before he had gone more than a few steps Rafe slipped in the mud, landing on his face. The elf back onto a broken leg, and screamed out in pain.

Rafe scrambled back to his feet to find the wet, glistening point of the unicorn’s horn in front of his chest.

“Don’t threaten me you damn beast! Try being useful instead.”

The unicorn ignored Rafe, dropped its head and looped the rope around its horn. Rafe grabbed the rope again and together they hauled a (the) soaked whimpering elf out of the bear trap.

He (Rafe) hadn’t seen an elf in years. They were normally aloof, ethereal and elegant. Collapsed into a soaking muddy heap the elf before him seemed tiny and pitiable. The broken bones looked particularly out of place in the elf’s narrow leg, more worryingly the whimpering had stopped. (confusing, delete or move)

The unicorn had dumped (dropped) the rope and now stood over the elf, nuzzling its arm gently. Rafe gently picked up the limp figure – he started to assume the elf was male now he looked closer, but it was very hard to tell - and draped him over the unicorn’s back. The unicorn kept a suspicious eye on Rafe, but it allowed the elf on his back without complaint.

“There, he’s out. You can come to my home and get dry, or you can trot off your own way,” Rafe said, feeling silly for talking to an animal. Rafe didn’t know whether to be pleased or annoyed when it started to follow.


End of Scene.


Rafe’s home was a single-roomed woodsman’s cottage with a thatched roof. The unicorn, being shorter and more slender than a horse, was able to fit through the door despite the passenger draped over its back. It looked around at the messed blankets and furs, piled up dirty dishes and other signs of the bachelor life and snorted horsily. (horsily...well ok. for MG)

“I’m sure you clean your own is spotless,” Rafe muttered. The unicorn didn’t respond.

Rafe stoked the fire up and placed the elf by it in the only comfy chair to dry off. Then he used the mercy of unconsciousness (no, just, no). He set the elf’s leg and splinted it as best he could, with the unicorn peering critically over his shoulder the whole time. He described what he was doing to the watching unicorn, which he decided to call Blossom, although it probably had some ridiculous name in Elvish.

Transferring the elf to his bed, Rafe gave Blossom an apple, settled down in the chair and fell asleep watching the unicorn nibble around the core.
Some I've just rewritten to save time. Green means delete forever or move to a later date, (usually specified)
In general, I think you're packing waaay too much into tight spaces. There's is no rush to tell us everything. We already have a trapped elf and a unicorn - that alone will keep most readers happy. You need to simplify your sentences. The best way is to just reduce the amount of words in them - see what you can do without, and still hold the intent and meaning of the sentence. Fancy writing is a bear like pitfall. Biggly.
 
Small point but if you're doing dialogue you don't use capitals e.g. “Anyone in the hole?” He called.
Should be "Anyone in the hole?" he called.
 
I like it! You could probably tighten up the prose a bit and shave a few off the word count. The idea is interesting, and takes familiar fantasy tropes (elegant, ethereal elves with musical voices) and puts it into an unfamiliar story and setting, and has a nice blend of surreal with mundane. You do a nice job establishing the characters in a short space (including the unicorn) and creating an interesting dynamic between characters (again, including the unicorn!). The characters and the situation has me interested enough I would want to read more.

I think the biggest thing is that the prose needs just a tad more polishing. For example, the first and fourth paragraph strike me as just a little off. Not much, but there is the sense that just a touch more editing could take 'okay' and make it 'excellent'.

But that's being slightly nit-picky, as I enjoyed the read and would want to read more given the chance!
 
Oh joy, Pam. 60K to reread and de-capitalise :-(
You can use Find and Replace in Word to help you with this ;)

'As if called by name, the first few heavy drops started thudding into the leaves and dirt around them.' This would benefit from being moved to the earlier paragraph so that the 'as if called by name' part relates to the storm. Where it is currently placed, I expected other elves to appear rather than raindrops.

I enjoyed the style. It fits for YA but, as a far from young adult, I found it an easy and intriguing read so I would think that adults who like light fantasy would read on. I would definitely read more.
 
Oh joy, Pam. 60K to reread and de-capitalise :-(

Asha beat me to it, but basically, you can at least find them with a search on quotation mark (though this won't be so simple if you've followed the British practice of single quotes for dialogue as it throws up apostrophes too) followed by a space. But I think you've used double quotes (American spec) so just search " (space) and that should at least put you near what you need to change.

If you know what they are likely to be you could use find/replace with caution e.g look for " H and specify " h as the replacement text. But you probably have quite a few personal names etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads


Back
Top