Your Personal Top 10 Speculative Fiction Authors?

This is extraordinarily difficult, as most of you have noted.

I suppose I should leave out "one hit wonders" like Daniel Keyes (Flowers for Algernon) and Charles G. Finney (The Circus of Dr. Lao) even though these are brilliant works of genius.

I need to limit myself to authors who have produced a reasonably large number of works of speculative fiction, and to those authors whose work was consistently (with perhaps a few minor exceptions; even Homer nods) of great interest to me.

I'm afraid this not only leaves out authors of immense importance to the field (Asimov, Clarke, and Heinlein come to mind, their later works being, shall we say, not indispensable on my reading list) as well as very important authors whom I either admire without being tremendously passionate about (Simak) and those who, for whatever reason, do not appeal to me (Van Vogt.)

I am also going to contradict myself and list some authors who went through periods, either early or late, in their careers when their work was not of great interest to me; yet their "classic" period includes so many fine writings that I find I cannot leave them off the list.

Just to make this immense task a bit easier for myself, I will also not mention any pre-Golden Age writers; farewell, H. G. Wells and Olaf Stapledon!

You will also notice a lack of "new" writers on the list, simply from ignorance on my part.

It may also be worth mentioning that I am probably going to be prejudiced in favor of authors who excel at short fiction, and against those who produce immense series of gigantic books. (There will be exceptions, I'm sure.)

With all that in mind, and knowing that there will be many, many names I will omit, here goes nothing.

Ray Bradbury -- Excessively sentimental at times, and verging on self-parody? Certainly, but also a writer whose sincere emotions are painted on the page in delicate pastels.

Fritz Lieber -- Extraordinarily elegant and witty, even able to elevate sword and sorcery, not my favorite genre, to the level of literature.

Theodore Sturgeon -- Master of style and wise in the ways of the human heart.

Cordwainer Smith -- Creator of new myths, unique in every way.

Philip K. Dick -- Erratic in many ways, overly mystical towards the end, and perhaps as mad as a hatter; yet what profound visions of reality of the nature of humanity!

Robert Sheckley -- The finest satirist in speculative fiction, worthy of sitting on the shelf next to Swift and Voltaire.

Ursula K. LeGuin -- A gifted stylist who reminds us, gently, of why what we are reading is important.

Harlan Ellison -- Pyrotechnic iconoclast whose best work goes far beyond speculative fiction to embrace all forms of literature.

Joanna Russ -- Polemicist, propagandist, always controversial; but a fiercely intelligent and immensely gifted writer.

Robert Silverberg -- Careless hack at first, but through sheer hard work created a large number of masterpieces.

Bah! That's ten, roughly in historical order, and I haven't even gotten to John Brunner or J. G. Ballard or Geoff Ryman or John Varley or Kim Stanley Robinson.

But one must start somewhere.
 
David Gemmell
Joe Abercrombie
Robert Fabbri
Clifford Beal
Colleen McCullough
Lindsey Davis
Scott lynch
Brian McClellan

I obviously have a strong leaning towards historical fantasy, or outright historical fiction. :)
 
It was hard to whittle it down to only ten authors, but anyway here is my list:

J.R.R. Tolkien
Stephen Donaldson
John Wyndham
Jack Vance
Frank Herbert
Bob Shaw
J.K. Rowling
George R.R. Martin
Joe Abercrombie
C.J. Cherryh

Honorable mentions go to Isaac Asimov, Arthur C. Clarke, Philip K. Dick, David Brin, Larry Niven, Ursula K. Le Guin, etc.
 

O. Smith? R.R. Martin? :)

Both terrific stories, Victoria. Leiber also produced arguably the cornerstone of the 20th century horror, "Smoke Ghost," a superb late career story, "Belsen Express," and at least one terrific (and amusing) ghost story, "Four Ghosts in Hamlet." His novella, "You're All Alone" is top-notch, as well, though it lost something when expanded (The Sinful Ones). Of those writers who began publishing in the 1930s, he was the only one I know of equally at home and influential in sf, fantasy and horror. (Although Sturgeon probably came close to that level, too.) His first collection, Night's Black Agents came out of Arkham House, known for Lovecraft and horror, and besides "Smoke Ghost" included "The Automatic Pistol," "The Hound," "Diary in the Snow" and a few other major entries in the horror story.

Anyway, Ray, I considered him for fantasy too, but I've read more of his horror than his S&S. If I'm speaking to the choir, sorry, but just for context: What we now consider urban fantasy/urban horror was just plain fantasy in the days of Unknown. The difference is that today it's in novel form, back in the 1940s it was coming out in short story form from Leiber, Sturgeon, Heinlein, Fred Brown, Eric Frank Russell, Anthony Boucher, Kuttner and Moore, and a bunch of others I'm probably forgetting. And -- I forgot to add before posting -- a lot of it wasn't just fantasy, it was horror, influencing somewhat later writers like Richard Matheson and still later writers like Stephen King.

Good post and almost makes me wish I'd bumped someone for him. I actually came to Leiber more from SF and then came to think of him more as a fantasy author but he's definitely a major horror writer (not a "gore-or" writer), too. Maybe that's where the emphasis should be but it is easier to just say he was one of the very, very few masters of all. I'm big on genre and big on SF, yet Leiber makes me not care.

(And agreed that Night's Black Agents is great - an essential collection.)

Since other folks are doing honorable mentions, let me do that, too :): Leiber (obviously),Brackett, Clement, Hamilton, Kuttner/Moore, Leinster, Simak; Anderson, Bester, Dick, Ellison, Emswhiller, Pohl/Kornbluth, Schmitz, Silverberg, Smith, Zelazny; Bear, Butler, Cadigan, Cherryh, Forward, Haldeman, Sheffield, Tiptree, Varley; etc. Probably still left out some.
 
I can't believe I missed a 'list thread' until now - too busy with work lately to pay correct attention to the goings on around here. Anyroad, enough waffle, here is my list in order I thought of them, based on favourite authors that have written many good books (taking the same approach as others that a few great great works don't make a summer), but making no claims that they are necessarily the best 10 I've read:

Isaac Asimov
Larry Niven
Poul Anderson
Arthur C. Clarke
Robert Silverberg
Clifford D. Simak
Philip Jose Farmer
Philip K. Dick
Alan Dean Foster
Brian Aldiss


I am going to need a quiet sit down and a cool beer having realised there wasn't room for Heinlein, Bova, Robinson, Banks, McDevitt or Harrison, all of whom could justifiably jostle for attention and selection. In fact any of them could nudge Aldiss out on a good day; I kind of mentally flipped a coin on my tenth pick. But I am happy with these ten. If I was stuck on a desert island and the desert island fairy said I could only read these 10 writers during my south seas stay I would be less stressed out than if she (he?) picked different names. All white male authors of a certain age and era I realise but I make no excuses or apologies for that, they're just my reading preferences. A certain member we no longer see here much would tell me off, but there we have it.
 
I obviously have a strong leaning towards historical fantasy, or outright historical fiction. :)

I think I'm going to have to update my current list. Need to read some of these authors more extensively, though:

David Gemmell
Joe Abercrombie
Robert Fabbri
Clifford Beal
Colleen McCullough
Lindsey Davis
Scott lynch
Brian McClellan
Ken Follet
Robert Harris
Lee Child
 
Jack Vance
Poul Anderson
Frank Herbert
Fritz Leiber
Michael Moorcock
Ursula LeGuin
Gene Wolfe
Dan Simmons
David Gemmell
George R. R. Martin
 
I left quality writers to me that i have read too little of so far for them to objectively make my top 10 list like these:
Roger Zelazny,Poul Anderson,Alfred Bester,Kuttner/Moore,Leiber,Robert Aickman, Tanith Lee

My personal top 10:

SF/Fantasy
Jack Vance
Lord Dunsany
Philip K. Dick
Leigh Brackett
Robert E Howard
Cj Cherryh

Horror
Edgar Allan Poe
William Hope Hodgson
Ray Bradbury
Richard Matheson

As you can see i prefer my horror to me the old school atmospheric strong like Poe or the weird-dark fantasy style ala Bradbury,Matheson.

Honorable mentions: David Gemmell, Tim Powers, Robert Heinlein
 
I left quality writers to me that i have read too little of so far for them to objectively make my top 10 list like these:
Roger Zelazny,Poul Anderson,Alfred Bester,Kuttner/Moore,Leiber,Robert Aickman, Tanith Lee

My personal top 10:

SF/Fantasy
Jack Vance
Lord Dunsany
Philip K. Dick
Leigh Brackett
Robert E Howard
Cj Cherryh

Horror
Edgar Allan Poe
William Hope Hodgson
Ray Bradbury
Richard Matheson

As you can see i prefer my horror to me the old school atmospheric strong like Poe or the weird-dark fantasy style ala Bradbury,Matheson.

Honorable mentions: David Gemmell, Tim Powers, Robert Heinlein

Nice List! I'm a big fan of Philip K Dick but I've only read the odd bit by most of the others so can't really comment. I've got some really nice editions of WHH's work and everything I've read has been very impressive.
 
Nice List! I'm a big fan of Philip K Dick but I've only read the odd bit by most of the others so can't really comment. I've got some really nice editions of WHH's work and everything I've read has been very impressive.

To make a list of only top 10 is really hard for me and doesnt say much more than current reading habits. I read so much SFF that i have close to 20 authors i call alltime favs ones. Philip K Dick is special to me since he is the first author that made me respect serious SF that is just quality stories asking questions like what it is to be human and that SF stories is to me everything but its SF setting.

Also i can change most of my top 10 for other personal favs its only Jack Vance/Lord Dunsany who can never be removed from any top 10 list since they are nr.1 alltime fav author in any field to me. I have no trouble changing great PKD and co for Heinlein,Gemmell,Powers,Tanith Lee etc

About William Hope Hodgson i like his writing so much, his wonderfully weird imagination that i was actually angry at WWI for killing such a talent so early in his life, another reason war is so pointless.....
 

Similar threads


Back
Top